(1) OK, if you say so, but I rewatched the second and 3rd quarters and did not see much in the way of open receivers. The Cards played a lot of 2 deep zone. Once the ball is in the air defenders leave their man or zone to go to the ball. This often looks like "open" receivers. By and large it looked to me that Johnson went to the "right" receiver but oftentimes his timing was slow (i.e., should have got the ball out a bit earlier in the route). He does not exactly have a laser arm and his passes tend to "hang" thus giving the DB more time to get to the ball. He was 5 of 12 the first half and 3 of 7 the second half. Not exactly the same game as he had the year before. On the Wildcat pitch back play he was focused on going deep to his left and definitely missed a wide open guy on the other side of the field.
(2) Undeservedly getting votes and consideration for a NC? Good loss for college football? Well, OK, if you say so. I think a lot of "football fans in the country" (but not UK fans
) would have been happy to see a newcomer crash the Old Boys Football Club but that's just me. Sagarin-wise, UofL finished #5, played the #27 SOS and went 3-1 against the Top 30. tOSU finished #4, played the #38 SOS (that includes their BCS opponent, #1 ranked FL) and finished 3-1 against the Top 30. FL clobbered tOSU in the game. May well have done the same to UofL.
(3) Yes, the Cards were looking pretty good and got up to #5 before that ugly Houston loss which was followed by a loss to UK as a 28 point favorite and a bowl beatdown by LSU. OTOH, the Rutgers loss was followed by winning out. I am not sure a 1 loss Cardinal team would have made the 2016 playoffs but am 100% sure an undefeated regular season in 2006 would have put the Cards in the BCS championship against FL.
Thank you, STUCK. Regardless of the other losses that year, that home field loss to UK as a HUGE favorite was absolutely brutal to the Cardinal fan base.
Peace