Rupp Rafters All-Time MLB Draft - Completed
- Thread starter DraftCat
- Start date
I love Nolan, always have, but yes, Satchel was better.
Dang it, that’s literally who I was going to take, man you snipped me LOl
Since I was snipped, I will go with greatest hitting catcher arguably, I go mike piazza. @dvillecatfan you are on the clock
Give me outfielder Dave winfield for LF or CF haven’t decided yet. @drcats2013 you are on the clock
Give me a former MVP that had 9 straight Gold Gloves. I’ll take Ryne Sandberg. @BigBlueFanGA youre up
I considered Ryne for my 2nd base need but I needed a great leadoff man even more. This guy is terribly undervalued. I'll take Tim Raines.
@JHannibalSmith OTC
Oh yea. He was high in my list for next round. Great pick
Yeah it was a coin flip for sure, pudge is the better defense Catcher for sure, piazza is the better hitter
Great job guys lots of picks in the last couple hours.
This guy may not have a sexy name compared to the other catchers already chosen... but he's #3 all-time in WAR behind Bench and Gibson.
Give me HOF Catcher Gary Carter.
@jcrow10 OTC
Give me HOF Catcher Gary Carter.
@jcrow10 OTC
Last edited:
Eddie Collins at 2B and because I need a solid 3B, I’m taking Nolan Arenado who has won 10 straight gold gloves and has over 300 HR. It’s hard to pick current players for this draft, but I think he’s a solid choice given that some of the historic 3B are off the list. @jcrow10 back at ya.
Lifetime .310 hitter with 2749 hits and 2 batting titles I'll take "Ol Aches and Pains" Luke Appling
I only need this guy to get on base with all my power hitters... he fits right in!
Fun Fact at the age of 75 in the Cracker Jack Old Timers Game he hit a HR off of Warren Spahn
@Cowtown Cat OTC
I only need this guy to get on base with all my power hitters... he fits right in!
Fun Fact at the age of 75 in the Cracker Jack Old Timers Game he hit a HR off of Warren Spahn
@Cowtown Cat OTC
2 very good picks.
Interesting thing about Arenado. I was in an extremely deep fantasy semi-keeper league years ago, and drafted him as a prospect when in AA. At the time the scouts said his bat was good, but they questioned his glove and thought he might have to move to 1B. Lol, scouting is not a science.
Yeah, he was never a homerun hitter but he got this one. I watch the video from time to time.
a lot more in this guy’s career left but the production so far, especially in last years playoffs was too much for me to let him go any further. give me bryce harper @Jsngabbard
