I know I'm not in this. But still found it interesting. From the leftovers, I've come up with this team:
1 Harry Heilmann (RF), .342 career ave, hit .390+ 4 times, 5 top 10 MVP, per162gm stats 14hr-116rbi
2 Al Simmons (CF), .334 career ave, hit .380+ 4 times, 8 top 11 MVP, per162gm stats 22hr-134rbi
3 Johnny Mize (1B), .312 career ave, .562 slug, .959 obp, 4 top 5 MVP & 7 top 12, missed 3 prime 30-32 years to WW2
4 Ralph Kiner (LF), .279 ave, NL hr champ 7 straight years, MLB champ 5 times, per162gm stats 41hr-112rbi
5 Bill Dickey (C), .313 ave, 5 top 8 & 8 top 14 MVP, per162gm 18hr-109rbi
6 Robinson Cano (2B), .301 ave, 6 top 8 MVP, per162gm 24hr-93rbi
7 Willie Wells (SS), .330 ave, negro league player, ranked 9th all-time SS by a composite site, per162gm stats 22hr-136rbi
8 Ken Boyer (3B), .287 ave, 1 MVP, 6 top 13 MVP, per162gm 27rbi-91rbi
Robin Roberts (SP), led NL in Wins 4 straight years, 6 straight 20+ Win seasons, 5 top 7 MVP
Mike Mussina (SP), 9 top 6 CYA
Bret Saberhagen (SP), 2 CYA, 3 top 3 CYA
Dizzy Dean (SP), 1 MVP, 3 top 2 MVP, 4 top 7
Dan Quisenberry (RP), 5 top 5 CYA, 5 top 11 MVP, led AL in saves 5 years, and just cool to have a submarine pitcher
Others considered:
Lajoie, Utley, Rolen, Minoso, Billy Williams, Jim Rice, Beltran, Andruw Jones
Cone, Stieb, Sabathia, Valenzuela, Tiant, Bunning, Drysdale, Kimbrel