Why is Knaak a major project? Please share your specific concerns. 6'7" 300# athlete who can play OT. Four years of eligibility left because he was redshirted in 2022. Offer sheet coming out of hs included nine Power 5 schools including UT, SoCal, and OR St who were nationally ranked teams in 2022. Considering that SLC doesn't produce a lot of impact Power 5 players, that's a pretty strong offer sheet under the circumstances. Since Knaak was judged worthy of a scholarship offer from Lincoln Riley, an offensive specialist, isn't he interesting as a potential impact lineman for us?
If you said Malachi Wood is a major project, you would be right for sure. Wood needs to add 30-40# of muscle and learn all the basics. But Knaak has a Power 5 body and apparently some athleticism.
OTOH, in view of the geography, I am skeptical at this point whether UK can attract Knaak. The last time UK signed a football player from the state of UT was Kurt Jackson and Jan Jorgensen in our 2003 class. AFAIK, Stoops has never tried to recruit a player from the state of UT. Knaak is a transfer, so maybe he looks at his options and decides UK is a good alternative if he is willing to relocate this far to the east. He would be an excellent alternative for our program because he has 4 years of eligibility and a Power 5 frame. Getting him on campus for a visit will be the key to a serious recruitment.
IMO, UK's starting 2023 OL is set except for a competition in August between Ford and Flax at RT. Flax isn't going to lie down, and the job has not been guaranteed to Ford. But OTOH, Ford was brought in specifically to compete for the starting RT job because Flax didn't nail it down this spring. Ford and Flax are experienced Power 5 players. Knaak is a redshirt freshman, so he probably wouldn't be a candidate to win the RT job in August. The value of signing Knaak, if we can, would come into play in 2024, after three of our 2023 starting offensive linemen graduate. The value of this recruitment is the four years of eligibility. That doesn't make him a project anymore than any other young offensive lineman is. He would have to learn the system and wait his turn. But Goodwin's, Young's, Buford's, and Wohlabaugh's outbound transfers and the upcoming senior graduations are eliminating close to half of our total OL roster.