It's been a whole week so just going to limit my response to this one post as everything can be found in earlier posts at this point. It's just a pink cake with blue frosting. He initially agreed to make the cake. Which means making a pink cake with blue frosting isn't against his religion. Making a blue cake with pink frosting for a trans person was the problem. He doesn't get to decide which cakes a trans person is allowed to have or not have. As the judge said, ""Here, the refusal to provide the bakery item is inextricably intertwined with the refusal to recognize Ms. Scardina as a woman. The concept that a business can decide whether to make the requested item depending on what information the customer provides would establish the equivalent of a 'Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell' rule — LGBT individuals would be entitled to equal service only to the extent they do not request goods that reflect their identity as LGBT individuals."