ADVERTISEMENT

Higgins Missed Calls Thread 2005-2017

Higgins-Officiated Games and UK’s Path the Final Four

The Path:
Something to consider is that historically speaking under Cal, UK has been in the Final Four if Higgins does not cross paths with Kentucky along the way, with the only exception being the 2016 matchup with IU. {He refereed in the 2010 Sweet Sixteen win and 2017 Elite Eight loss in addition to our 2011 and 2015 Final Four losses}.

UK's Final Games of the NCAA Tournament from 2010-2017 are listed below, with Higgins-officiated games in bold:

2010: Elite Eight Loss to WVU (previous game vs Cornell officiated by Higgins)

2011: Final Four

2012: National Champions

2014: Championship Game

2015: Final Four

2016: 2nd Round Loss to Indiana

2017: Elite Eight Loss to UNC

Seen from another angle, when UK has played in the NCAA Tournament during the Cal era, we have made it to the Final Four every year except one (2016) when Higgins has not been an official in any of our previous games.

In the Final Four:
If UK is in the Final Four, we have lost when he was on the whistle, but advanced when he was not (see 2011, 2015 Final Four losses + 2012, 2014 Championship Games).


The chances of UK making and winning a Final Four are exceptionally high if Higgins in not a factor (again, there’s only ONE exception and that was in a rival game).
--

Here's to a fair NCAA Tournament. Go 'Cats!
--
UPDATE: The post above was written prior to UK’s 2018 Sweet Sixteen loss to Kansas State, officiated by Jamie Luckie, Chris Rassatter and Earl Walton. Luckie also officiated our Elite Eight heartbreaker to WVU in 2010. A separate Thread is devoted to “Jamie Luckie and Kentucky” at https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/jamie-luckie-and-kentucky.263353/ . There were 51 fouls in that game, with brutal calls on both teams. It wasn’t a lopsided affair like Higgins or Sirmons-officiated games. It’s the way Luckie calls games and when compared one with another, can be similarly described as a brutal, rough foul fest. They are not fun to watch. We’ll add him to the list of officials that make UK’s path the Final Four more difficult.
 
Last edited:
Marshall vs. Wichita State

Yesterday’s Higgins-officiated game (March 16, 2018) of Marshall vs. Wichita State had highly controversial calls. For the record, here are some threads with more info and live reactions:

https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/higgins-trying-his-best.261745/

https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/ncaa-round-1-day-2-tourney-thread.261725/page-3

https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/john-higgins.261689/


Marshall ended up winning that game, but not before the final minute took 18 minutes, 26 seconds in real time,the longest on record in tournament history (at least since it's been tracked). It should be noted that by this time, Wichita State had run out of time outs.

http://www.kansascity.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/for-petes-sake/article205574414.html

http://www.businessinsider.com/marshall-upsets-wichita-state-long-final-minute-2018-3

Quote: “The result was yet another exciting addition to a series of March Madness upsets, but the end of the game was marred by a series of questionable calls and painfully long reviews by officials.”

http://ftw.usatoday.com/2018/03/wichita-state-marshall-officials (including twitter reactions)

Typically, teams from Kansas and Wisconsin, plus Duke and UNC usually win if Higgins is on the whistle. Kentucky, SEC teams in general, Virgina, West Virginia and Oklahoma are likely to lose. This game had a different ending, with a West Virginia team, Marshall, pulling off the upset.


On Sunday, Marshall will meet fellow in-state team West Virginia. WVU Coach Huggins has a long history with John Higgins and it would not be good for the integrity of the sport if he were allowed to officiate that game (see previous posts in this Thread for the long history between them). Higgins is in San Diego, so there’s a chance he could officiate their game tomorrow (although in light of the history, I would think whoever decides this will put him on the other game). It was only this season that Huggins publicly criticized how Higgins and Crew officiated their game vs. Kansas (Kansas shot 35 free throws compared to WVU’s TWO!). Coach Huggins was even reprimanded for being outspoken (here’s threads discussing it: https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/...in-the-now-famous-35-2-kansas-swindle.258739/ AND https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/...s-and-ive-wondered-the-same-for-years.258242/ ).

Here’s to a fairly officiated Tournament!
 
Last edited:
2017 Elite Eight vs. UNC - "Foul on Willis"

As we get ready for tonight’s Regional/Sweet Sixteen game, here’s video from last year’s Regional Final/Elite Eight. Here’s a “foul” on Derek Willis:

It looks like fellow referee Mike Reed disagreed with the call (see 7-10 second mark).

Mike DeCourcy, in this article,
http://www.sportingnews.com/ncaa-ba...lite-eight-results/1s87ijvzm6qbq1kbin53htwgfb describes what happens in this video well:
“There were some curiosities, though, particularly with the first-half officiating. On three occasions, official John Higgins observed action and did not blow his whistle to call a foul on Kentucky until the outcome of the play turned in UK's favor.

The most notable of these occurred with Carolina attacking its goal just before the four-minute mark. UNC point guard Joel Berry was unable to control a poor pass, and Wildcats forward Derek Willis reached to the floor attempting to grab the ball. Berry lifted his hand trying to gather the ball and struck Willis’ wrist. The ball deflected high in the air and was retrieved by UK center Isaac Humphries. Higgins’ whistle blew right then.”
--
The score at the time was UK 30, UNC 34. With Humphries’ gaining possession of the ball, it was a potentially momentum-shifting play. But that moment was taken away by a very questionable whistle, which also gave a much needed shooter his second foul of the game.

Here’s to a fairly officiated Sweet Sixteen! Go ‘Cats! GO BIG BLUE!
 
Last edited:
I will never forget or forgive that robbery....ever. Just maddening. Perhaps our good karma will continue for 2018. Go cats.
 
March 26, 2017 - One Year Ago Today

One year ago today, Kentucky lost by 2 points to UNC in an Elite Eight thriller officiated by John Higgins. The whole world saw on display what UK fans had been upset about for years, and at first, many in pro sports or media agreed with us and voiced their opinions and it looked like our concerns were being heard. In a couple days’ time, the overwhelming media attention took a few unfortunate turns and some forgot the real issue at hand: that John Higgins does not call a good Kentucky game. We do not know the reason, but we do know it to be true. We saw it happen in the heartbreakers of 2005, 2011, 2015 and 2017.

Many fans could not get over the loss in 2015 because there were so many egregious calls or no calls. Adding insult to injury, to have our game tied on a shot clock violation left far too many “what ifs”. We were told because we had our chances to win---and we did---to be quiet and not cast blame. But when it happened again last year, in such similar fashion, we could not stay quiet. Over the last year, this Thread has been dedicated to posting stats from our Higgins-officiated games. Some more will still be posted as we approach the end of March Madness 2018.
 
Last edited:
Higgins Not Calling Sweet Sixteen, Elite Eight or Final Four 2018

The Sweet Sixteen and Elite Eight were held this week. John Higgins was not on the whistle for any of these regional games for the first time since 2010. Last night some of us were wondering why (https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/kansas-vs-duke.263460/page-3#post-6796288 and https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/higgins.263597/ ). We awakened this morning to news that he, along with Doug Shows, Kelly Self and Dwayne Gladden, did not continue to the Sweet Sixteen or Elite Eight regionals over an officiating error where the wrong Auburn player was sent to the foul line in a potentially game-changing free throw situation (https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/higgins-not-working-final-four.263717/ ). While Higgins was not on the whistle, he was an alternate and was overseeing the review monitor. See: http://www.kentucky.com/sports/college/kentucky-sports/uk-basketball-men/article206816604.html (I’m not linking the original Goodman-ESPN article).

Higgins will not be working the Final Four for the first time since 2013 and it's only the 2nd time he has not called Final Four or Championship since 2010. The other time was 2012. Those who made this decision should be commended for taking action. Without making these issues about the referees personally, which is a distraction to the real issue, we should keep raising our voices concerning fair officiating. Too many games with certain referees have been too close in the final minutes to have lingering “what ifs” hanging over their memory.
 
UK vs. UNC - Elite Eight 2017

The Final Seconds




UK players getting mugged under the basket with no calls. Does Monk get fouled on his 3 pointer?
 
Final Four, April 4, 2015 vs. Wisconsin
2 Points for Wisconsin


Wisconsin’s Koening goes out of bounds, regains the ball before his feet hit the floor, scores and it’s 2 points for Wisconsin.

 
It's disturbing how obsessed UK fans are with this man.
maybe so (we do obsessive better than anyone), but you have to admit, the evidence is fairly compelling. And I'd forgotten about DeCourcy's words, quoted above. He's pretty good - and not some delusional BBN yokel hell bent on a conspiracy theory...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lumpy 2
Remembering 2015 on this Championship Game Day

As the 2018 Championship will be held tonight, here’s a video flashback from April 4, 2015, the final 3 minutes of our Final Four vs. Wisconsin. Here’s the play-by-play: http://www.espn.com/mens-college-basketball/playbyplay?gameId=400787769



The 2015 Wildcats didn’t have the opportunity to play in the Championship Game, and we will never know how it would have turned out had the Final Four been officiated well, but that team will always hold a special place in the hearts of the BBN.[/MEDIA]
 
Last edited:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgins,_North_Carolina
2whjok6.jpg
 
I know about Big Blue History's site but is there a place to find other teams records when Higgins officiates?
 
I found this site for UNC which lists refs. Is there one for Duke or Kansas?

https://dadgumboxscores.com/officials/

Including last night's Stanford game, UNC is now 6-4 when Higgins officiates.

Losses
Georgetown 06-07 (Elite Eight)
Texas 09-10 (Regular Season)
Villanova 15-16 (National Championship Game)
@Clemson 17-18 (Regular Season)
 
The NY Times has an article this morning about officiating entitled “The NCAA Team That Just Can’t Win”.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/20/sports/ncaa-tournament-referees.html

It starts off with “The knowing nods come as soon as the name John Higgins is mentioned to veteran college basketball officials. It could happen to any of us, they say, the way things are going.

Higgins is one of the top referees in the sport. But it was during a taut N.C.A.A. tournament matchup in 2017 that he trended on Twitter and quickly became the target of harassment by frustrated Kentucky fans certain that Higgins was the reason that the Wildcats had lost a quarterfinal game against North Carolina.

. . . a lawsuit that Higgins later filed against a radio station he accused of fanning the discord. . . . “ END QUOTE

Never does the article even look at the facts of that 2017 game, or why fans might have been upset. The article then focuses on blaming coaches for their example in leading fans in bad behavior. It even compares the amount of Cal’s salary per game to what a referee makes per game.

The article does end with one honest referee who admits he makes mistakes: “. . . The game was a testy one, headed to overtime, between teams desperate to reach the N.C.A.A. tournament. In the second half, McCall called a foul on an Arizona State player who blocked a shot. The Sun Devils’ coach, Bobby Hurley, was enraged. Replays on the enormous video board sent Hurley into a frenzy. Fans howled insults at the officials.

A night earlier, as cheers from a nearby game swirled into a dim arena hallway, McCall had discussed the occasional blown call, and the outrage that was sure to follow one.

‘The only times I really remember when I look back over my career are the mistakes I made — the mistakes that were critical mistakes, at critical times of a game, that maybe changed the outcome,” McCall said. “And I don’t need to read anything on social media to know, believe me.’” END QUOTE

It’s worth a read, but terribly one-sided, and explains that coaches are getting “clamped down on” more now than before in an effort to rein in behavior. Here’s a quote: “. . . This season, the N.C.A.A. put a renewed focus on bench decorum, hoping to clamp down on the boorish behavior of coaches — who might set an example for fans. Coaches are restricted to a short stretch of sideline where they often pace impatiently, like caged cats, while barking incessantly, like neighborhood dogs. . . .” END QUOTE

Can’t help but think of Cal’s bowing gesture during Saturday’s loss to UT when, despite his many earlier protests, bad calls kept being blatantly made.
 
They missed a perfect opportunity to get a peak at his "roofing business" finances since, I believe, one of his claims was that it hurt business.

If I'm not being clear, I think his business is a sham to hide his gambling returns and kick backs from fixing games. But that's just my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowtown Cat
There have been a number of John Higgins Threads already posted so far. I thought it might be good to have a dedicated Thread to post his missed calls.

First, a little background. . . .

Here’s his record officiating Kentucky games: http://www.bigbluehistory.net/bb/statistics/Officials/John_Higgins.html

Would like to have his record vs Cal at UMass and Memphis.
There’s another Thread about that (https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/higgins-vs-cal-at-umass-memphis.232113/).

Here’s some of the recent Threads on this board related to Higgins:
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/john-higgins-ref-for-tomorrow.231561/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/tubbys-2005-loss-higgins.232114/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/decoursy-sporting-news-on-officiating-and-higgins.232051/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/cal-calls-out-officials.231957/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/tom-leach-pounding-the-refs.232080/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/dear-matt-jones.232079/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/if-unc-wins-the-title-give-john-higgins.232075/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/...st-ky-and-terrible-seeding-towards-uk.231978/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/worst-calls-of-the-game.231889/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/...ly-called-one-technical-in-7-uk-games.231712/
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/...icials-for-tonights-game.231093/#post-5781208

To clear up a few misconceptions: No, he did not call a technical in every UK game he officiated. No, we have not lost every game he officiated. No, he is not related to Ellen Calipari, although that is her maiden name. No, he is not related to the famous now-retired referee Tim Higgins. {But he does have a brother named Tim, who also played basketball and was a referee http://www.lopers.com/news/2015/6/8/MBB_0608153516.aspx and http://lopers.com/hof.aspx?hof=206&path=&kiosk=}

But it IS TRUE that we have never won an Elite Eight or Final Four Game that he has officiated. Even the UCLA regular season game he officiated in December had questionable calls. If we win that game, our seeding might have been different.

Here’s an old radio interview where he casually dismisses non-reviewable missed calls: http://kxno.iheart.com/onair/the-morning-rush-52935/referee-john-higgins-talks-dunks-his-14445856/

Here’s a couple feature stories on him:
http://netnebraska.org/article/news/1067762/nebraska-basketball-referee-has-earned-his-stripes
http://www.si.com/college-basketbal...recognized-referee-well-traveled-john-higgins

Some of our biggest tournament losses were games he officiated:
2005 Elite Eight Double Overtime to Michigan State
2011 Final Four loss to UConn
2015 Final Four loss to Wisconsin
2017 Elite Eight to UNC

(A note about 2017 Seeding: Going into the Tournament, in the national polls, UK was ranked #5 and UNC was ranked #6 and #8, as well as UCLA [flipped polls]. In the regular season, UCLA beat us; they were the South's 3 Seed. In the regular season, UK beat UNC; UK was the #2 Seed to UNC's #1 in the South Region. UK faced 3 teams in the Tournament who had 30 wins; according to Corey Price, this was a "first" in NCAA Tournament History).

Every one of those losses Higgins officiated were controversial and he is a common denominator. These were games where a “little” call –or no-call—here or there made a big difference.

If anyone has video clips or still shots of missed calls, let’s post them here!

You need to get over this. Geez.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT