A quick Google search says Chicago and Cincinnati have about the 10th-highest murder rate per capita in the country. Louisville isn’t far behind.
worldpopulationreview.com
Evidently St Louis has given up fighting crime the most, about 3x as much as those first two.
Look a little closer at those stats, and they start to fall apart.
Murder rate per capita obviously depends not only on the number of murders but the number of people who live in the city.
St Louis is listed as having a population of 295,000 people.
Louisville is listed as having a population of 616,000.
Is Louisville really more than twice the size of St. Louis?
Cincinnati apparently has only 305,000 people.
So the longstanding GYERO argument is settled - clearly Louisville is the major city, not Cincy.
In fact, Louisville is even bigger than Atlanta (524k people), if we are to believe these numbers.
And Tulsa OK is bigger than Pittsburg, St Louis, Cincinnati, Cleveland, and New Orleans.
In other words, those numbers are garbage. They're probably using population in the actual city limits, which vary hugely from city to city. In some cities, you're out of the city limits as soon as you leave downtown. In other cities you can be 40 miles from downtown and still in the city limits.