Head to head, Cal has totally dominated Pitino. Not to mention the fact that Pitino is persona non grata now in the state of Kentucky because he is a liar and an adulterer who flashed the finger to our fans. I don't like what Cal has done to our basketball program, but it still miffs a lot of people including me when the subject of Pitino comes up.
With the HUGE advantage of coaching at UK, yeah he dominated, going 8-2 against Pitino. But, while at UK, RP was 4-1 against Calipari. Same win percentage, he just wasn’t here as long as Calipari & didn’t play against Calipari coached teams as often. When neither is coaching UK they are 4-4 all-time. As I said in another thread, the only fair way to judge, IMO, is to compare their results as coach at UK.
As a prelude I’ll say that I wanted Calipari in 2009. He was my top choice & he did an amazing job in his first 6 seasons. But, he coached here in a far less competitive era than Pitino & has had 3 disastrous seasons, while causing more apathy in the fanbase than every other UK coach in my lifetime, combined.
It was the polar opposite with Pitino. He brought the excitement back & took us from a no talent team on probation to national title contenders within 3 seasons. Hell, he won the SEC regular season championship in his 2nd year, while still on probation.
Pitino’s teams were dominant in a much stronger era & we were a 1 seed 4/6 years that we were eligible for the NCAAT. We were a 2 & a 3 seed the other 2 seasons. We were always peaking in March & in the championship discussion, if not the favorites, every year we were eligible, aside from 92, which was a masterful job just getting us to a 2 seed & region final. And, also in 94, when we were a 3 seed & we lost Rodney Dent 11 games into the season, which threw a major monkey wrench into the situation.
And again, Pitino went 14-14 with a bottom feeder OVC level roster & Calipari went 9-16 with 3 NBA players & Terrence Clark, who would’ve been a 4th, in the weakest era of CBB in my lifetime. He’s missed the NCAAT, completely, twice & has a humiliating 1st round loss & a 2nd round clunker on his resume, here, too.
RP took us to at least the E8 in every season that we were eligible except for the 2nd round loss in 94. After going 14-14 in year 1, he never lost more than 7 games in any other season, here, & he averaged 31 wins per season in our NCAAT eligible years from 92-97, including going 97-12 in his last 3 seasons. He left us as the clear #1 program in the greatest era in CBB history.
Calipari is no saint either, having wins & FFs vacated at every stop aside from UK. So far, anyway. I’m not saying Calipari has always been a bad coach. He’s in the HOF for a reason. But, that’s not the coach he’s been for the last 8 seasons & as good as he was in his prime, he’s never approached RP’s level as a HC, all things considered. He was thought of as discount Rick Pitino when he was at UMASS & that hasn’t changed, IMO.