I don't care what anybody is saying right now. The risk for re-injury is going to be higher on the front end of recovery timeline, no matter what the severity is. At the very least, we should expect a very heavy minutes restriction if he sees game action this Fall.If he’s cleared in sept and held out until SEC play that’s lunacy. With all the focus on JQs dad being adamant his son will be ready by September baring a setback, he will be playing in games in November. I read it was a partial tear. He didn’t have a blowout of the knee a partial tear. The more this has played out it’s seems to me expected he will be on the court for most if not all the start of the season. This guy needs the stage. He could be a top 5 pick if he plays to his potential and there are marquee matchups prior to sec that I’m sure he wants to play in.
No doubt, I definitely want him to play I just think he should play very limited minutes the first half of the season into the New Year.I'm an advocate of getting him minutes in November. Maybe not extended minutes, but as a big, it's critical that he gets experience in the trenches against the insane OOC schedule we have. If he's asked to run the offense at all, he's going to need November to learn as much as possible before conference play.
It's a catch-22, honestly. Rest him and make sure there's no doubt he's healthy, but he maybe doesn't get to really learn the team and system for a while... OR play him early so he can reach more or his potential by March, but that risks reinjury.
I suspect Pope will get JQ some extended run against the weaker OOC opps in November but maybe pull his minutes back against Michigan State, St. John's, and other physical teams that make it a point to bust other teams' tails.
It’s the negative Nellies on this board that talk about holding him out. It’s a worrisome group.Agreed. And the longer you wait to play him, the higher the chance that it messes with the team chemistry and the less time he has to get back in playing rhythm. If the docs say he's good, let him play. I honestly believe he wants to.
Racing the throngs of numbskulls who believe JQ can magically heal faster than 99.9% of other basketball players with the same injury. Why? Because his dad and some reporter said so. Never change RR. Never change.![]()
And here come the Rupp Rafters Orthopedic Surgeons offering their medical expertise!!
So you’re saying JQ is full of shit and lying when he says that what his Dr told him? I don’t see anyone saying he has magic heels, I see people saying if he is cleared then let him play. Most people have enough common sense to know it’s a best case scenario. Your post in this thread seem to go pretty conceded or negative.Racing the throngs of numbskulls who believe JQ can magically heal faster than 99.9% of other basketball players with the same injury. Why? Because his dad and some reporter said so. Never change RR. Never change.
Has anyone given thought that when JQ is back healthy he may not be able to break into the starting lineup. We may end up with better talent than JQ at the 5. Just thinking out loud.Agreed, I’d prefer he take it easy, practice with extended rest and wait until around December to really ramp it up. I know they can get guys pretty well fast, but taking the proper time and rest will benefit us more to make sure his knee is ready to go. It will take time getting confidence to play like he used to as well.
If we do then we will be way better than expected. Defensively alone he’s a top 10 type pick. He has better defensive metrics than AD and Noel did. He should be ready to really get going here soon. Second college year with his talent. He’s getting the age he should be in college. He should be damn good.Has anyone given thought that when JQ is back healthy he may not be able to break into the starting lineup. We may end up with better talent than JQ at the 5. Just thinking out loud.
Irving also sat out an entire season at duke due to a toe injury. He’s glassBeyond the obvious of Irving being far older in basketball terms that JQ, there's this extensive injury history:
- 2015 Injury:
In 2015, Irving fractured his patella during the NBA Finals and underwent surgery to repair it. Screws and a tension wire were inserted to stabilize the fracture.
- 2018 Initial Surgery:
In March 2018, Irving had a procedure to remove the tension wire, which had been causing irritation. During this procedure, a bacterial infection was discovered at the site of the remaining screws.
- Second Surgery:
The second surgery, performed in April 2018, involved removing the infected screws and addressing the infection. The Celtics announced that the kneecap was structurally sound and healed, but the tension wire had been causing pressure.
SINCE 2018, he's gone on the IL for the following: Hip strains, sore quads, sore knee, sore back, hamstring, groin, ankle, calf, foot...I don't know if you are counting, but that's just about everything that can go wrong in a leg.
Trevon Brazile is a better comp for a worst-case scenario, if that's your thing.
Torres doesn’t know shit, he just recycles information that’s typically common knowledge.
This is by no means a bad report, I just don’t believe he has any inside track here.
I think he's blindly optimistic at best.So you’re saying JQ is full of shit and lying when he says that what his Dr told him? I don’t see anyone saying he has magic heels, I see people saying if he is cleared then let him play. Most people have enough common sense to know it’s a best case scenario. Your post in this thread seem to go pretty conceded or negative.
My son had the same injury (maybe worse) and was cleared 1 day short of 6 months for full speed and no restrictions for football practice. It really depends on who is the surgeon and rehab. My son got the best available in SoKy and NoTn. He was the former surgeon for the Titans.Kyrie Irving had the same injury at about the same time. His expected date to return is sometime in January. I am not saying JQ can't do it but, why the months difference in return times. I have never heard of a 6 month recovery, then, full return for this type of injury. I hope this is the exception.
AgeKyrie Irving had the same injury at about the same time. His expected date to return is sometime in January. I am not saying JQ can't do it but, why the months difference in return times. I have never heard of a 6 month recovery, then, full return for this type of injury. I hope this is the exception.