I’m a huge Stoops fan … but also acknowledge the program has platued, or even trending in the wrong direction. History reveals that Stoops has accomplished what many/most football experts thought was impossible, while also declining the last couple of seasons. Both facts can be correct.
The biggest question is what is best for UK football moving ahead. This topic probably deserves its own post, but I’ll throw out a couple thoughts. First, people are naturally against the incumbent in many arenas and coaches are no different. (Research anti incumbency bias) Claiborne, Curry, and Brooks were excellent football minds who could not consistently accomplish what Stoops has accomplished at UK. (Throw the multitude of excuses in the garbage. UK will always have several disadvantages. It ultimately comes down to wins/losses.) Fans who think top young coaches will line up for the UK job and automatically improve UK football are wearing blue tinted glasses and are ignoring both HISTORY and PRESENT DAY reality.
Second - Fla, UT, SC, Aub, etc … have much richer football history and several other recruiting advantages over UK. How has the coaching carousel worked for them??? Those jobs are more desirable than UK. Fla is getting ready to fire their 3rd coach in 10 years. UT went through Dooley, Jones and Pruitt in less than 10 years. Auburn was paying 3 head coaches and are close to adding a 4th one to the list while they still flounder around. Bottom line - hiring a new coach is a role of the dice with less than 25% of them lasting more than 3 years! And, this is at programs who have some history of winning!
I ignore the “fire Stoops” posts and realize most of them are emotional posts with no real logical thoughts about the program.
Stoops has proven he has a plan for recruiting that is working. Again, he has improved the program in ways that many experts did not think was possible. He’s definitely going to get another year unless he personally walks away. He’s earned the right for another year. However, the program is trending in the wrong direction. UK MUST improve and win more games. I don’t know the magic number of wins next year, but I know the losses can’t look as bad as the games against SC, Vandy, and Fla. It’s one thing to compete and lose against likely playoff teams. However, we can’t look as inept as we have in some of our bad losses.
I’m pro-Stoops, but he’s got to right the ship.