ADVERTISEMENT

Spin-off: Best one-hit wonder ever

Hendrix is not a “one hit wonder.” He was an FM radio act - an album act, not a singles act. A one hit wonder is an artist who has only one song that people know.
 
Hendrix is not a “one hit wonder.” He was an FM radio act - an album act, not a singles act. A one hit wonder is an artist who has only one song that people know.
That is technically incorrect.

"Yes, Jimi Hendrix is considered a one-hit wonder by the strict definition of the term:

  • Definition
    An artist who has only had one song enter the top 40 of the Billboard Hot 100 singles chart

  • Hendrix's hit
    "All Along the Watchtower" was Hendrix's only hit, reaching number 20 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1968
The Jimi Hendrix Experience – All Along The Watchtower (Official Audio)


Hendrix was known for his experimental sounds and blues-rock, which was not very popular with teenagers in the late 1960s. He was also better known as an album artist. "
 
Hendrix released four studio albums and all four were Top 10 in the US and Electric Ladyland went to number 1. So your source saying that he “was not very popular” is idiotic. There was a big difference starting in the late 60s between album acts and singles acts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tskware and parrott
Hendrix released four studio albums and all four were Top 10 in the US and Electric Ladyland went to number 1. So your source saying that he “was not very popular” is idiotic. There was a big difference starting in the late 60s between album acts and singles acts.
That source did not say that.


Teenagers bought singles.

Adults Albums.
 
Last edited:
Aha - take on me
Six mix a lot- Baby got back
Gotye- somebody i used to know
Gerardo- Rico Suave
Right said fred- I'm too sexy
 
How "What's up" became a hit is beyond me. For me, that's the worst song I've ever heard. It has zero redeeming qualities and the singers voice? Up there with Yoko Ono as the worst female "singers" ever in my book.

I watch YouTube and find random videos that interest me.

Saw one of Pink singing "Whats Up" (which was great by the way) and she introduced the song by saying she has been including it in her shows for more than ten years. Lady Gaga also has a version which is pretty cool.

Moral to the story is that at least some other well known artists think it is worthy of including in their live acts (which of course doesn't mean you have to like it)
 
You must have forgotten the gem “Glamour Boys”. It’s amazing the same band sang those songs.

Wasn't as big of a hit, and not one I appreciated near as much at the time.

That's a great point though. That was such a great time in music as so many were experimenting with different sounds, rather than staying pegged into a static style. It's pretty awesome to go back and listen to some of the groups from the late 80s into the mid90s that produced music for music's sake rather than style over substance for money.
 
Someday I Suppose was big enough to not warrant them being called a One Hit Wonder.

Not to me, but it's a cool song. I tend to think of hits not just as hitting in the top 40 but for longevity, local popularity, and air play at the time.

That cover by The Hollies above was huge for over a decade where I lived and with the families we knew back then. A lot of military families. My dad, like a friend of mine's dad did as well, carried one of his siblings to school and home again daily when they were kids. Song means a lot to both of us and our families to this day.

Will always be that way while I'm still breathing.

Eric Carmen
All By Myself

Was a one hit wonder like that for me as a kid as well. Didn't hear another song of his I liked much, though he had a hugely popular one in the 80s I think.
 
Not to me, but it's a cool song. I tend to think of hits not just as hitting in the top 40 but for longevity, local popularity, and air play at the time.

That cover by The Hollies above was huge for over a decade where I lived and with the families we knew back then. A lot of military families. My dad, like a friend of mine's dad did as well, carried one of his siblings to school and home again daily when they were kids. Song means a lot to both of us and our families to this day.

Will always be that way while I'm still breathing.

Eric Carmen
All By Myself

Was a one hit wonder like that for me as a kid as well. Didn't hear another song of his I liked much, though he had a hugely popular one in the 80s I think.
Eric Carmen also had “Hungry Eyes” and “Make Me Lose Control”. Loved the latter.
 
I Melt with You, Modern English
Life in a Northern Town, Dream Academy...they had another minor hit.
Under the Milky Way, The Church (Australian Band)
The Promise, When in Rome....I don't know of any other hits but I was a Joe Dirt style rocker by then and didn't listen to pop. Great song.
Forever Young ,Alphaville (Germania)
Send Me an Angel, Real Life

And the winner is:




I am unsure...those were very good.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT