You know your stuff but I’m not buying this is a “very poor” version of 2012.
Just off the top this team’s guards are deeper and maybe better overall.
Haven’t seen Edwards play but is he that far behind MKG? Push?
Jones and Davis plus Miller are hard to match.
Overall depth is better this year and we sure weren’t saying that 3 weeks ago.
I hope you are right, but looking at this 12 vs. ‘24 on paper.
PG Teague vs. Wagner- ranked about the same spot, I actually think Wagner will be better.
SG Lamb vs. Reeves- Lamb by a country mile.
SF Kidd-Gilchrist vs. Edwards- ranked about the same, but it would surprise me if Edwards turns out to be that good. MKG was a beast and a great leader as a Freshman. And built like a grown man.
PF Jones vs. Mitchell- Mitchell will be good, but he is not on Jones’ level.
C Davis vs. Bradshaw- highly unlikely that Bradshaw or anyone on this roster is remotely as good as AD. AD was a once in a lifetime freak of nature. Expecting Bradshaw to be that good is asking a lot.
Bench
Miller vs. Dillingham- Miller was a 6’8 Senior with guard skills and could play almost any position. On paper, no one on this roster is like that. Dillingham could match his scoring, but won’t shoot it like Miller.
Vargas vs. Onyenso- probably a push. Vargas was a grown man, though. He wasn’t really needed as much as Onyenso will probably be needed.
Wiltjer vs. Thiero- probably a push. Wiltjer was likely better on offense and Thiero will be better on defense. Wiltjer was a great shooter, but his defense was atrocious.
2012 didn’t go much deeper than 8, but next year’s team has Sheppard, who could play meaningful minutes.
So the ‘12 starters are, IMHO, way better than ‘24 on paper.
‘24 might have slightly more depth, but if you can avoid injuries, depth doesn’t really matter past your 8th man.
So I stand by my “very poor man’s” description.