ADVERTISEMENT

Reds

Between Casili and Maile, it seems like Maile might have put together a season so far that might garner him some interest in a package trade deal. I like Casili in what he brings in experience helping the young pitchers, but he brings nothing offensively. I'm just not seeing what Barrero is bringing to the table yet. if they cut ties with him, It wouldn't be a big loss. Obviously the ship has sailed on him being the SS of the future. That's in EDLC or McClain's hands at this point.
Frankly, the Reds can't keep pandering to sub .220 hitters like Barrero or Myers who do something once in a blue moon. A catcher probably does go and roll the dice that nothing happens to Stephenson. As noted already, should the worst case scenario happen if the catching depth gets wiped out, Chuckie Robinson is down in Louisville hitting nearly .340 gaining valuable experience with the young pitchers and worked with many of the current Reds pitchers last year.

I get Barrero is young, athletic with raw tools but AAA is where he belongs since he isn't about to go anywhere for the next few years. Doesn't need to be in Cincinnati taking AB's away from players who are the reason Cincinnati is in the mix currently who are the future while he tries to figure it out. Sitting the bench doesn't help him either. It does not do the Reds any justice while they are trying to build and contend with what they have. The best thing for Barrero right now is to get optioned back to Louisville and retool. He is an offensive liability and whatever he is doing obviously is not working. His ceiling to me is that of one Angel Berroa the Royals had in his best year. Fluked his away into the AL Rookie of the Year and didn't do shit there after once the league figured him out.

"Berroa is an excellent natural athlete, and this shows up strongly on defense. His range, arm strength, and hand coordination are all excellent. He makes too many errors, but is more reliable than he used to be, and this will improve with time. Questions continue to revolve around his bat. He has power, but struggles to control the strike zone."
^Other than the too many errors part which I'll give him credit for his defense & versatility, everything else sounds just like Jose.

Agree that SS ship has sailed on Barrero with the current crew and we all know how many SSs the Reds have in the minors. His future here is if he can hit consistent enough to ever grab an outfield spot or a super utility role. As long as Friedl & Fraley are healthy, Steer in the outfield equation now, you have two outfielders in Benson & Fairchild playing decent right now. For how long, I don't know but more consistent than Barrero has ever been who has only put together 1 or 2 good games in a row with regular playing time.

Whether people like it or not, Senzel & Votto are coming back and will remain to be seen how long Wil Myers lasts in a Reds uniform. One the Reds should consider trading, Kevin Newman. No he doesn't kill the Reds but he's just going to continue to lose playing time with all of these infielders coming off the IL. No other way around it. There are just not going to be enough AB's to go around for players like Barrero, Newman, Myers, a 3rd string catcher & Hopkins as much as I hate that he hasn't gotten a real shot. If Benson & Fairchild go into another slump, then the Reds should most definitely give Hopkins a chance that everyone has been given being 26 years old now.
CES started in RF tonight.


Did not see this coming.
 
Last edited:
Probable pitchers for the Astros & Reds series

Tonight Abbott vs JP France 2-1 3.54 ERA
Sat Greene vs Brandon Bielak 3-3 4.01 ERA
Sun Weaver vs Ronel Blanco 1-0 3.86 ERA

Yordan Alvarez put on the IL for 4 weeks a couple of days ago. Lance McCullers, Luis Garcia & Jose Urquidy on the IL. All things considered, with the Reds playing better this is about as good of timing as you can ask for going into Houston. At least they're not facing Christian Javier, Framber Valdez or Hunter Brown. Hope the Reds make the most of it.

 
Probable pitchers for the Astros & Reds series

Tonight Abbott vs JP France 2-1 3.54 ERA
Sat Greene vs Brandon Bielak 3-3 4.01 ERA
Sun Weaver vs Ronel Blanco 1-0 3.86 ERA

Yordan Alvarez put on the IL for 4 weeks a couple of days ago. Lance McCullers, Luis Garcia & Jose Urquidy on the IL. All things considered, with the Reds playing better this is about as good of timing as you can ask for going into Houston. At least they're not facing Christian Javier, Framber Valdez or Hunter Brown. Hope the Reds make the most of it.

Aw, but that would have been fun watching Hunter Greene Vs. Hunter Brown.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: The-Hack
Good god Reds benched EDLC in favor of Senzel, the apocalypse is near. Benches a generational player with power and great speed for a .250s singles hitter with a "sore knee."
 
Last edited:
Good god Reds benched EDLC in favor of Senzel, the apocalypse is near. Benches a generational player with power and great speed for a .250s singles hitter with a "sore knee."
Up 2-0 on the Astros in the 9th. Two on. Tyler Stephenson on 1st. Why would you not pinch run EDLC for him at this point? Does Steer bring on second negate the need for that?
 
Still not sure why they took Abbott out after six Innings of shutout ball and he only through 83 pitches. But it worked out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jameslee32
Good god Reds benched EDLC in favor of Senzel, the apocalypse is near. Benches a generational player with power and great speed for a .250s singles hitter with a "sore knee."
I think he was 0 for the Royals series, maybe just wanted to give him a day off after the team day off yesterday.
 
Good god Reds benched EDLC in favor of Senzel, the apocalypse is near. Benches a generational player with power and great speed for a .250s singles hitter with a "sore knee."
It worked!

Calm down. They gave the youngster a day off!
 
One hell of a start to a MLB career for Abbott!
I like it because I can drink like a fish and still calculate his ERA to the third decimal. And after my fifth beer, I can calculate his ERA to the third decibel!

It’s early, but something about his style reminds me of Greg Maddox (Hack said as he put on a flack jacket!).
 
Tyler Stephenson finding some power recently after the collarbone injury and with multiple threats in the lineup will continue to get good pitching. Feel like he will be the unsung hero on many nights like tonight with his home run. Benson continues to get and excellent speed to warrant his playing time.
 
Bats started CES in LF last night. Rece Hinds continues to be on a heater with another home run for the Lookouts, 6 home runs & 11 RBIs in the last 5 games.

 
Last edited:
It worked!

Calm down. They gave the youngster a day off!
It did? Senzel was 0-4 with another K, now "hitting" in the upper .240s. Senzel doesn't get credit for timely hitting by TS/Newman. Bell almost killed the offense with that move.

Abbott's success is storybook. Reds catching Houston at a good time with injuries to some of their top hitters/pitchers.
 
It did? Senzel was 0-4 with another K, now "hitting" in the upper .240s. Senzel doesn't get credit for timely hitting by TS/Newman. Bell almost killed the offense with that move.

Abbott's success is storybook. Reds catching Houston at a good time with injuries to some of their top hitters/pitchers.
De La Cruz hasnt gotten a ball out of the infield in a week. Its been disgustingly bad. He needed a break, and like Bell said, to slow things down and get back to baseball. It worked, because the Reds won their 6th in a row and are a half game out of first.

I seriously think you would bitch if the Reds won the World Series. You would find something to gripe about and type FO at least 93 times like you do in all of your posts.
 
De La Cruz hasnt gotten a ball out of the infield in a week. Its been disgustingly bad. He needed a break, and like Bell said, to slow things down and get back to baseball. It worked, because the Reds won their 6th in a row and are a half game out of first.

I seriously think you would bitch if the Reds won the World Series. You would find something to gripe about and type FO at least 93 times like you do in all of your posts.
Just giving an opinion, that's what people do on message boards. If you don't care for my opinion fine, don't read it or block me.

I can actually recall the Reds winning a WS, I'd love to see it again. Won't happen with current ownership/FO, they lack the creativity needed to make such a run but they could decide who does win. The young guys are fun to watch but they need to play instead of propping up guys like Senzel, a .250s singles hitter with limited XBHs despite playing every day minus the 12 games just missed with a "sore knee." Reds gave up on Barrero, won't give CES a sniff yet cater to Senzel as if he's the second coming.

Greene today, let's see if Bell lets the one generational player he has back on the field.
 
Just giving an opinion, that's what people do on message boards. If you don't care for my opinion fine, don't read it or block me.

I can actually recall the Reds winning a WS, I'd love to see it again. Won't happen with current ownership/FO, they lack the creativity needed to make such a run but they could decide who does win. The young guys are fun to watch but they need to play instead of propping up guys like Senzel, a .250s singles hitter with limited XBHs despite playing every day minus the 12 games just missed with a "sore knee." Reds gave up on Barrero, won't give CES a sniff yet cater to Senzel as if he's the second coming.

Greene today, let's see if Bell lets the one generational player he has back on the field.
Hopefully if he does play he won't go 0-4 again with 2 K's and 2 weakass groundouts to the shortstop.

Pretty much anyone that actually follows the Reds knows the front office has accumulated awesome talent and has them positioned for a really nice 4-5 year run. There are other awesome players on the field besides EDLC. With more waiting in the wings in the minors because the FRONT OFFICE made great trades and drafted well. The future is bright, but if it makes you feel better to incessantly bitch and whine about the front office that accumulated this talent, knock yourself out. Im an enormous Bengals fan too because I live in the area. You probably still bitch about Mike Brown, too.
 
Hopefully if he does play he won't go 0-4 again with 2 K's and 2 weakass groundouts to the shortstop.

Pretty much anyone that actually follows the Reds knows the front office has accumulated awesome talent and has them positioned for a really nice 4-5 year run. There are other awesome players on the field besides EDLC. With more waiting in the wings in the minors because the FRONT OFFICE made great trades and drafted well. The future is bright, but if it makes you feel better to incessantly bitch and whine about the front office that accumulated this talent, knock yourself out. Im an enormous Bengals fan too because I live in the area. You probably still bitch about Mike Brown, too.
Don't give a hoot in hell about the NFL. I. Don't. Care.

Sorry you hate the one player that can take the Reds to the heights you want. SMH.
 
Don't give a hoot in hell about the NFL. I. Don't. Care.

Sorry you hate the one player that can take the Reds to the heights you want. SMH.
I love the guy. Ive been over to see him play 4 times now. Have you??? I just understand that with all the hype that has surrounded him he was slumping and needed to get his head straight. Hopefully he comes out tonight with a new approach and makes the team even better.

And baseball takes a helluva lot more than 1 guy. Ask Mike Trout.
 
I love the guy. Ive been over to see him play 4 times now. Have you??? I just understand that with all the hype that has surrounded him he was slumping and needed to get his head straight. Hopefully he comes out tonight with a new approach and makes the team even better.

And baseball takes a helluva lot more than 1 guy. Ask Mike Trout.
I don't live in the area, have seen EDLC play every game he's been up on TV. Wished I could see him live. I'm just stunned at the disdain you have for the guy in the very short time he's been in Cincy while claiming to be a Reds fan.

Yes, you need more than one guy but what you DON'T need is a roster of .230-.250 singles hitters. Reds need to move on from those guys. Reds have had a good run in the last 10 days-2 weeks. Let's see if they can maintain.
 
I don't live in the area, have seen EDLC play every game he's been up on TV. Wished I could see him live. I'm just stunned at the disdain you have for the guy in the very short time he's been in Cincy while claiming to be a Reds fan.

Yes, you need more than one guy but what you DON'T need is a roster of .230-.250 singles hitters. Reds need to move on from those guys. Reds have had a good run in the last 10 days-2 weeks. Let's see if they can maintain.
Seriously, you have some issues. Disdain?? I pay to go watch the guy. I was at his very first game, went because they called him up.

You are whining and crying like a little bitch because he didnt play last night. Good lord give it a rest. We won.
 
Tyler Stephenson finding some power recently after the collarbone injury and with multiple threats in the lineup will continue to get good pitching. Feel like he will be the unsung hero on many nights like tonight with his home run. Benson continues to get and excellent speed to warrant his playing time.
Benson will have an opportunity because the OF is where the PT will be for the most part. The infield looks pretty much set if Steer is the 1st baseman of the future and why wouldn't he be?

C Stephenson
1B Steer
2B India
SS McLain
3B EDLC
 
Seriously, you have some issues. Disdain?? I pay to go watch the guy. I was at his very first game, went because they called him up.

You are whining and crying like a little bitch because he didnt play last night. Good lord give it a rest. We won.
Why do you feel compelled to attack me personally? You're a very small person.
 
Benson will have an opportunity because the OF is where the PT will be for the most part. The infield looks pretty much set if Steer is the 1st baseman of the future and why wouldn't he be?

C Stephenson
1B Steer
2B India
SS McLain
3B EDLC
I just don't see the numbers working for India to stay at 2B full-time once Marte is ready, which could still be around a year from now. They've seemed more willing to move Steer around than India, so I'll assume he's destined to be the LF. I tend to think India is headed toward 1B or DH and then play 2B on days when other guys need days off.
 
I just don't see the numbers working for India to stay at 2B full-time once Marte is ready, which could still be around a year from now. They've seemed more willing to move Steer around than India, so I'll assume he's destined to be the LF. I tend to think India is headed toward 1B or DH and then play 2B on days when other guys need days off.
FWIW and don't know how you feel about the MLBN but most of their talking heads see McLain as the Reds 2B long term with EDLC at SS, Steer to LF. Still think the Reds will offer India for a SP(I know that's not popular), something the Reds will need long term. That would open 1B for CES, 3B for Marte in late '24.
 
FWIW and don't know how you feel about the MLBN but most of their talking heads see McLain as the Reds 2B long term with EDLC at SS, Steer to LF. Still think the Reds will offer India for a SP(I know that's not popular), something the Reds will need long term. That would open 1B for CES, 3B for Marte in late '24.
I tend to agree with them. My guess on the post-trade deadline Reds when healthy:

Catchers (2)
Tyler Stephenson
Curt Casali OR Luke Maile

Infielders (5)
Joey Votto
Jonathan India
Elly De La Cruz
Matt McLain
CES

Outfielders (4)
TJ Friedl
Jake Fraley
Will Benson
Stuart Fairchild

Utility (2)
Spencer Steer
Nick Senzel

I think the easiest thing to do through the rest of this year is keep EDLC at 3B most days and keep McLain at SS. Steer can still play 1B occasionally if needed but I think he's heading toward LF for the most part. Senzel shouldn't play against RHP but would def play him against LHP. Fairchild isn't an everyday player but I really like him on the bench. Good speed, good defender and isn't a complete liability at the plate. He's earned a spot on this team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kybloo92
I tend to agree with them. My guess on the post-trade deadline Reds when healthy:

Catchers (2)
Tyler Stephenson
Curt Casali OR Luke Maile

Infielders (5)
Joey Votto
Jonathan India
Elly De La Cruz
Matt McLain
CES

Outfielders (4)
TJ Friedl
Jake Fraley
Will Benson
Stuart Fairchild

Utility (2)
Spencer Steer
Nick Senzel

I think the easiest thing to do through the rest of this year is keep EDLC at 3B most days and keep McLain at SS. Steer can still play 1B occasionally if needed but I think he's heading toward LF for the most part. Senzel shouldn't play against RHP but would def play him against LHP. Fairchild isn't an everyday player but I really like him on the bench. Good speed, good defender and isn't a complete liability at the plate. He's earned a spot on this team.
I could buy that but I don't think Barrero's done just yet. He's only 25, really good athlete with nice power. Fenway grand slam, line drive CF hit that could've taken Kershaw's head with it have been forgotten. Reds off season will be interesting, should be moving guys.
 
I just don't see the numbers working for India to stay at 2B full-time once Marte is ready, which could still be around a year from now. They've seemed more willing to move Steer around than India, so I'll assume he's destined to be the LF. I tend to think India is headed toward 1B or DH and then play 2B on days when other guys need days off.
Anything's possible with the DH.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The-Hack
Votto is signed thru next season but 2024 is a club option to pay him $20 million or buy him out for $7 million and send him on his way. A trade seems likely as well.
 
He looked fresh and efficient through 6, so who knows?
The thing that bugs me a little bit is they could have given the bullpen another day's rest. Diaz has been pitching a whole lot lately and looked a little tired in the 9th.
 
I hope Senzel is dealt tonight. Haven’t been a fan of his at all since he was drafted. To me he’s just an average utility player that can’t stay healthy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: barbourfor3
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT