Jerry Meyer doing his typical Jerry Meyer thing- basically, begging for attention by having some dramatic differences from everyone else.
I agree that Tatum should not really be mentioned as the top player in the class. He's just not explosive enough as an athlete, which might be OK if he was a great shooter, but he's not that, either. I would certainly take Giles and Jackson ahead of him, and arguments can be made for guys like Fox, Smith, Monk, and so on. But 12 is just dumb. I don't think the guy is superlative enough to be talked about as the best player in a loaded class, but he's still really, really good.
And I like Fox, but seriously- you're going to take him ahead of Giles, a 6'10" beast athlete with decent skills? You can do that if you want, but I'll take Giles and be 100% confident that if everything else is equal, I'm going to kick your ass.