The measuring stick only counted for Kentucky vs. Louisville?
What about Kentucky vs. UMass when Pitino was at UK?
What about Memphis vs. Louisville?
Prior to Cal arriving at Kentucky, Pitino's record against Cal was 7-5. They were 4-4 against each other at the comparable Memphis/Louisville.
Pitino was 3-1 against Calipari when Pitino was at UK.
I wouldn't call that "owning" anyone. I'd call that a case of both coaches doing better against the other while at UK, and when they had comparable programs, being neck and neck.
The real evidence for the better coaches is what they did at UK. You guys keep getting off that point as that is actually the whole argument here. We're not arguing about who has done better overall; we're arguing about who was better at Kentucky.
When eligible, Pitino went to the Final Four 50% of the time, and went to the Elite Eight 83% of the time.
Calipari's not even remotely close to those numbers.