You're right, let's forget all about the entire 2012-2013 season, especially the month post-Noel ACL tear and being humiliated by Tennessee, the probation era, multiple seasons of mediocrity at the end of Tubby's tenure, two seasons of irrelevance and embarrassment where we lost to teams like Garner Webb and VMI. No, no, going to a Final Four and missing out on recruits, (In a class where we already had the #1 ranked player per multiple services.) ranks right there at the top of the list.
Perhaps on a certain level, I am right. Let me explain. First, I was clear when I established the window at "thirty days". Second, disappointment implies there was an expectation. When Noel went down, it essentially negated any expectation for the rest of the season. Did you honestly expect a tournament bid on selection Sunday of 2013? The second Vandy ran UK out of the gym in the SEC tourney, nary could a UK fan be found who was predicting what seed Kentucky would earn. A historical, once in a generation, push toward 38-0 with 9 future draft picks, however, tends to lend itself to disappointment when a title doesn't happen. When those draft picks aren't replaced and 5 straight recruiting failures occur (all within the same 30 day period I established as my time table), again, the implied disappointment compounds even more.
Also, your referencing the BG years as some sort of comparable disappointment is also curious. Those teams were lacking in talent, quality, and any other type of measurable positives. The fact that BG had two total draft picks on those teams is telling. One of those picks, Joe Crawford, was a 2nd rounder who blew away in the league like a tumble weed.
On a personal level, probation to me was the darkest time in UK history, but it took some time for it to play out and I was specific when I wrote "thirty days". It should be noted that the UK program was already under an unassuming stranglehold with Sutton at the helm, long before the scandal broke. When the scandal did break, I don't think too many UK fans were surprised, especially in retrospect (although perhaps the penalties were surprising). Now, would I measure the last month of UK hoops as worse than probation? Absolutely not. That would in fact be insanity. But if we're talking a 30 day period where reality and expectation never correlate? Then yes, I'd choose the last 30 days over any period in UK history.
I'm sure folks will continue to disagree with my point, even with me having illuminated what I mean by "disappointment." I didn't say the "worst" time or "UK's darkest period", etc. I was clear when I wrote "disappointment" based on a thirty day window. That's okay, though. I have my opinion; they have theirs. It's all good.
Last edited: