ADVERTISEMENT

Reds

Earth to Reds FO: I realize this is beating a dead horse but you're playing in a HR hitter's park. Playing singles station to station baseball won't cut it. You have HR/extra base hit hitters in AAA. Don't you understand what you need to do??
While the Reds are near the bottom in HR's, they're amazingly middle of the pack in runs scored.
 
He looked so good but he's been getting lit up lately.
Seems like that's how last year went after he got called up. Started out gangbusters, looked like a future star his first 4 or 5 outings before things started to go south for him.
 
The Reds are going to have a very good hitting lineup here shortly but I'm really worried about the pitching. Louisville Bats had a 9-0 lead tonight after an inning and a half, it's now 11 to 11. I just don't see any pitching in the minors.
Is the problem more in not having bull pen depth in the minors or starters? Or has the rotation and injury issues depleted the depth in the minors?
 
110 pitches is child's play for his arm. Completely asinine decision by Bell, as usual. Instead of having a chance at history, this will simply be nothing more than a quality start with a W. Greene should have refused...period.
 
Holy shit! Just got home and saw a 7-0 lead, the Reds hits (15) and a Greene no-hitter! The box score shows 0 HR's and that's okay by me.
 
The best moves the Reds can make would be to promote from within calling up CES, EDLC, Lyon Richardson, Abbott & TJ Hopkins. Get them some meaningful experience this year. Don't mortgage the future trading away top prospects for rentals Cincinnati can't afford anyway. Would have then lost the prospects plus the veteran. It's the only way to sustain success than these quick 2-3 windows to contend in followed by another fire sale. Use the money coming off the books once the Griffey, Moustakas/Votto 2024 buyouts are through and continue to extend the current players like they did with Hunter Greene. That's how Tampa Bay does it and no reason with the loaded farm system for Cincinnati not to be able to do it in the years to come.
 
Absolutely nothing left to prove.
What it proves is that the player clock/TOS excuse is invalid now that we've seen Williamson, McLain & Stoudt all make their MLB Debut so there is no reason to keep holding them down at this point.
 
17 runs 31 hits and another one left to play in Chi-town.
Don't forget in the game previous to this series the Cubs were slaughtered by the Mets, Tucker Barnhardt pitched the final inning. NLC teams are leaving a lot to be desired.
 
The best moves the Reds can make would be to promote from within calling up CES, EDLC, Lyon Richardson, Abbott & TJ Hopkins. Get them some meaningful experience this year. Don't mortgage the future trading away top prospects for rentals Cincinnati can't afford anyway. Would have then lost the prospects plus the veteran. It's the only way to sustain success than these quick 2-3 windows to contend in followed by another fire sale. Use the money coming off the books once the Griffey, Moustakas/Votto 2024 buyouts are through and continue to extend the current players like they did with Hunter Greene. That's how Tampa Bay does it and no reason with the loaded farm system for Cincinnati not to be able to do it in the years to come.
This. They’re 4 games back going into today. Nobody is saying go out and get rentals for a pennant run. Just bring up what you’ve got in the system and start tinkering with getting them where they’re going to be long term. Now is as good of a time as any. They’ve got nothing to lose and everything to gain. DFA, demote, whatever, Meyers, Newman, Casili, to make room. Get what you can at pitcher for Senzel and Barerro at the trade deadline.
Do this.
ELDC at 3rd
McClain at SS
India at 2B
Steer and CES platoon at 1B and rotate as DH with Tyler Stephenson on the other days. I know Votto will have to play into the mix this year at some point. But he’s gone after this year.
Bring up Hopkins too.
 
Don't forget in the game previous to this series the Cubs were slaughtered by the Mets, Tucker Barnhardt pitched the final inning. NLC teams are leaving a lot to be desired.
All the more reason to see what they have and call the guys up. If they can push for a NLC pennant by working with what they have, they’ll better know what they need to firm things up for a stronger run next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The-Hack
Ashcraft gets a win but walking too many guys and too many pitches over the plate lately. Still the difference in this series has been pitching and the Reds bullpen has been solid other than Gibaut and Herget.
broom-sweep.gif
 
Ashcraft gets a win but walking too many guys and too many pitches over the plate lately. Still the difference in this series has been pitching and the Reds bullpen has been solid other than Gibaut and Herget.
broom-sweep.gif
We'll see how this all holds up. Month ago this team minus McLain couldn't get the ball out of the infield now they're riding a spark from McLain/Steer all be it vs the Cubs. If the FO would just grow a pair and take the next step maybe they could accidently contend.

BTW, mlb.com said this week Diaz was one of ten guys who'd likely be traded this summer but the Reds would set his price very high. How do Reds fans here feel about that?

Poor Senzel, old boy is dumber than a coal bucket.
 
We'll see how this all holds up. Month ago this team minus McLain couldn't get the ball out of the infield now they're riding a spark from McLain/Steer all be it vs the Cubs. If the FO would just grow a pair and take the next step maybe they could accidently contend.

BTW, mlb.com said this week Diaz was one of ten guys who'd likely be traded this summer but the Reds would set his price very high. How do Reds fans here feel about that?

Poor Senzel, old boy is dumber than a coal bucket.
Series like this only maintains the status quo making the FO feel like geniuses (they're not but at least Dick Williams is gone). But I'm actually amazed how well the offense and bullpen has done so far. And yes, the weak division helps a lot!
 
We'll see how this all holds up. Month ago this team minus McLain couldn't get the ball out of the infield now they're riding a spark from McLain/Steer all be it vs the Cubs. If the FO would just grow a pair and take the next step maybe they could accidently contend.

BTW, mlb.com said this week Diaz was one of ten guys who'd likely be traded this summer but the Reds would set his price very high. How do Reds fans here feel about that?

Poor Senzel, old boy is dumber than a coal bucket.
Moving Diaz would fit this Front Offices MO to a tee. Do they just not place any value in a quality closer?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mrschwump
Keep Diaz, in pre-arbitration through 2024 and should be in no rush to move him. 2024 does not have to be a bad season if the Reds get EDLC, Abbott, CES, Hopkins etc up here soon with enough experience to potentially contend next year. If not, 2025 and already have one of the best young closers in MLB with Diaz. They let Raisel Iglesias go for nothing. Received a joke pitcher named Noe Ramirez the Reds wound up sending back to the Angels and currently out of baseball completely. Hell, the Reds are only 3 back of a WC spot and 4 GB in the division just days from June. Diaz needs to be one of the players extended when the huge contracts start coming off the books.
 
We'll see how this all holds up. Month ago this team minus McLain couldn't get the ball out of the infield now they're riding a spark from McLain/Steer all be it vs the Cubs. If the FO would just grow a pair and take the next step maybe they could accidently contend.

BTW, mlb.com said this week Diaz was one of ten guys who'd likely be traded this summer but the Reds would set his price very high. How do Reds fans here feel about that?

Poor Senzel, old boy is dumber than a coal bucket.
There is zero reason to trade Diaz right now and realistically not going to find anyone better to step in his place. Cubs gave up Gleyber Torres for 2 months of Aroldis Chapman and Cincinnati has team control with Diaz so the asking price should be sky high. He's worth holding onto and see where this team can go in a couple years. The Reds should not even be considering trading any young, productive player at this stage of a rebuild. Goes for Jonathan India & Spencer Steer too. You know what you have with them unlike anyone who has yet to even make their MLB Debut. Trading any of these young, talented players now and the Reds would find themselves with even less experience prolonging the rebuild. Hope this FO will be patient and not trade away the players who belong in a Reds uniform.
 
Last edited:
There is zero reason to trade Diaz right now and realistically not going to find anyone better to step in his place. Cubs gave up Gleyber Torres for 2 months of Aroldis Chapman and Cincinnati has team control with Diaz so the asking price should be sky high. He's worth holding onto and see where this team can go in a couple years. The Reds should not even be considering trading any young, productive player at this stage of a rebuild. Goes for Jonathan India & Spencer Steer too. You know what you have with them unlike anyone who has yet to even make their MLB Debut. Trading any of these young, talented players now and the Reds would find themselves with even less experience prolonging the rebuild. Hope this FO will be patient and not trade away the players who belong in a Reds uniform.
No one in their right mind wants to see India or Steer get traded. Take those 2 out of the lineup and they'll be lucky to score 5 runs a week. Regardless how many infielders they have coming up, some of the prospects are going to be traded. All there is too it.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT