OT...Who you got?

[dvillecatfan]

I'm going with Dickerson.

 

[Grumpyolddawg]

I might could have tackled Dickerson, not sure I could Campbell.

 

[Girthang]

I might could have tackled Dickerson, not sure I could Campbell.

I could have tackled either in my prime, but definitely would've preferred to tackle Dickerson

 

[secrules3]

Could have tackled either but Dickerson would have been a MF'r to try and stop. Campbell would have just been a giant collision.

 

[catben]

Love big Earl and Bum would have ran him 60 times a game if he had to!!!

Dickerson was amazing also could cut and go better than anyone!!

2 totally different runners who both were the best at what they did.

 

[Finna_Go_HAM]

Dickerson was one of the all-time best. He had speed, moves and strength, but I'm taking Campbell. Tackling Earl Campbell was like trying to tackle a bulldozer. Earl was faster than most remember, though, and is one of the main reasons the NFL did away with tearaway jerseys. Dandy Don Meredith used to call him the Tyler (Tx) Bowling Ball.

 

[pauled]

Both of them were freaks of nature! In just different ways! Tackling either would have been a chore!

 

[Jroid1979]

I think it’s hilarious that anybody on this board thinks they could have tackled either one of them. Dickerson would have ran around and past you and Campbell would have ran over your ass. NFL players had trouble tackling them. I don’t care how big and strong fast you thought you were but you weren’t NFL big and strong and fast or you would have been in the NFL. Lol. Those posts are 😄 funny