I kind of agree on your premise on its face. But if we change the framing just a little bit I think it breaks down.
Let's just use Bin Laden as an example because it's easy. Do you think that someone who organizes and carries out a terrorist attack that kills around 3,000 people deserves to be brought to justice and killed? I think we can all agree, even if we don't agree with the concept of the death penalty, that we all smiled a bit the night he was killed.
Now what about a CEO that makes decisions that kills more people, or bankrupts people with medical debt, so his company can make billions and billions of dollars in profit? Is killing in the name of capitalism somehow less deserving of justice than doing it in the name of religion or hate or whatever motivation you want to assign to Bin Laden?
United Healthcare had a net income of $23 billion dollars last year. They are absolutely rolling in cash, and while they do so they're putting systems in place to deny more and more claims so they can make even more money. Even if the CEO wasn't directly responsible for the decision to use AI to deny claims, he's the CEO and he's responsible for what his company does.
A few weeks ago health insurance companies started saying they were only going to cover anesthesia during surgery for a set amount of time. If your surgeon is slow or if there are complications tough shit, you're getting hit with a massive bill. In what world is that just? It's worth noting that since this CEO was killed they all backtracked on this decision.
So should we be outwardly celebrating the death of someone like this? Probably not but I'm not going to really tell anyone who is that they shouldn't be. He made decisions that killed people, made sick people suffer, or saddled people with mountains of medical debt.