UL fans aren't thumping their chest but it shows they are closing the gap. When you're growing a program, closing the gap on the teams ahead of you is important. It's important for our football program to continue to make strides. If you can close the gap and be competitive with UGA and Bama, then you have most likely climbed into a new tier in terms of success.
Take Florida and Kentucky as an example. In the 5 years prior to Stoops arrive, Florida beat us 63-5, 41-7, 48-14, 48-10 and 38-0. In Stoops first 5 years, we went 0-5 against UF, but we also closed the gap losing 24-7, 36-30, 14-9, 45-7, 28-27. Outside of the 1 loss, it showed our program was making strides to even the playing field with Florida. In the next 6 years, we beat UF 4 out of 6 years. Closing the gap on programs that have traditionally kicked your ass is a sign of progress, hoping for the next step like we did with Florida,
Your basketball analogy doesn't fit here because we haven't been chasing UNC and Kansas to get to their level.
I just disagree completely that if our football team closes the gap on Bama and UGA, that it doesn't show signs that are program is drastically improving.