Everyone is now a paid mercenary. The tops teams will be who has the most money to pay. The smaller colleges don't have a chance. I will still watch it because it is in my blood, but it won't be the same.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
NIL isn't the issue. The instant transfer element is where 100% of the problems lie.They need to take 1 thing away. Either Nil or the portal and I think would be much less chaotic.
You can't cap NIL without collective bargaining. So that won't happen. The NCAA and NBA can't collude and the NBA's draft eligibility requirements are collectively bargained. So no lawsuit would be successful. I believe Mike Williams from USC tried to sue for eligibility to the NFL draft back in the mid2000s and lost. So those deals are pretty iron-clad.The transferring is out of control. Limit the transfers to once and make it so that you play two years before you can move unless there is a coaching change or some other unseen catastrophe.
Cap NIL at the school level. Set a limit for all schools and that's it.
Also make the NBA open the doors to high school kids, even if it means a lawsuit.
It’s both. Or, more accurately, the combination of both. As @bthaunert has pointed out, these are the two most monumental changes in the sport in like the last half century. If just one had happened without the other, the sport would’ve been able to better figure out how to adapt to it in a rational manner. But for both to occur at essentially the SAME time is insanity.NIL isn't the issue. The instant transfer element is where 100% of the problems lie.
Not if you sign with a school and have to get an education. What a concept, loyalty to a school. Maybe soldiers can sign NIL deals, get paid for the number of kills they can confirm.Keep in mind, if the transfer portal and instant eligibility didn't exist. We likely would not be able to field a team next season.
What about a salary cap as is MLB and NFL?NIL isn't the issue. The instant transfer element is where 100% of the problems lie.
Pay the kids, fine, but make them wait a year before they transfer. This would significantly reduce the transfer portal, build more roster continuity, and make the college game exponentially more enjoyable.
It would also stop most of the tampering that is occurring.
Agree.NIL isn't the issue. The instant transfer element is where 100% of the problems lie.
Pay the kids, fine, but make them wait a year before they transfer. This would significantly reduce the transfer portal, build more roster continuity, and make the college game exponentially more enjoyable.
It would also stop most of the tampering that is occurring.
You can sue for anything. Just say that the rule is age discriminations and go. Even so, it might not be the best idea.You can't cap NIL without collective bargaining. So that won't happen. The NCAA and NBA can't collude and the NBA's draft eligibility requirements are collectively bargained. So no lawsuit would be successful. I believe Mike Williams from USC tried to sue for eligibility to the NFL draft back in the mid2000s and lost. So those deals are pretty iron-clad.
NIL is the issueNIL isn't the issue. The instant transfer element is where 100% of the problems lie.
Pay the kids, fine, but make them wait a year before they transfer. This would significantly reduce the transfer portal, build more roster continuity, and make the college game exponentially more enjoyable.
It would also stop most of the tampering that is occurring.
Yes. NIL was ok, but now it's open bidding free agency with shady agents and gambling interests. NCAA should have regulated NIL so players had to raise their own money without agents. They don't want any more court cases so they've completely given over to this.They need to take 1 thing away. Either Nil or the portal and I think would be much less chaotic.
Those were collectively bargained by the players associations. Until players unionize and agree to framework with "salary caps" and other things it will continue to be a free for all.What about a salary cap as is MLB and NFL?
Then penalties to keep it honest.
Fines plus a loss of scholarship for grossly exceeding the cap.
So basically a free market? Thought that's what most people want?The courts have been very clear on this. The NCAA is not legally allowed to limit a player's earning potential or their freedom of movement to another school.
Greed has yet to kill any sport, unless you want to argue World Cup. That crap is more corrupt than the mob.Greed will kill college sports,both coaches and players will lose out!
Exactly a free market. And everyone wants a free market until they're affected by the negative sides of said free market.So basically a free market? Thought that's what most people want?
Greed will killcollege sports,both coaches and players will lose out!everything!
And give them benefits.The NCAA can’t hold people out a year when they transfer, because the second they did, someone will sue to say they should be classified as employees, they will win, and the NCAA would be required by law to suddenly take on tens of thousands of employees.
I think Mayberry disappeared in 1979 when Bird and Magic faced off and BIG TV figured out they had something.Mayberry is gone, and was gone when they started paying coaches millions of dollars.
Exactly a free market. And everyone wants a free market until they're affected by the negative sides of said free market.
Okay.Those were collectively bargained by the players associations. Until players unionize and agree to framework with "salary caps" and other things it will continue to be a free for all.
The courts have been very clear on this. The NCAA is not legally allowed to limit a player's earning potential or their freedom of movement to another school.
True.Exactly a free market. And everyone wants a free market until they're affected by the negative sides of said free market.
There’s no reason to have instant AND unlimited transferring. The game has turned into a big game of musical chairs.NIL isn't the issue. The instant transfer element is where 100% of the problems lie.
Pay the kids, fine, but make them wait a year before they transfer. This would significantly reduce the transfer portal, build more roster continuity, and make the college game exponentially more enjoyable.
It would also stop most of the tampering that is occurring.
Yeah and a long one in Fayetteville too🤣🤣🤣Kentucky fans complaining that the transfer portal is ruining college basketball after spearheading the one and done era is hilarious. Just because no one wants to go to Kentucky anymore now there is a problem with kids only playing one year. It's going to be a long year in Lexington. 😂😂😂