I thought our resident St. Looey Card and baseball expert Bernie -- and others -- might weigh in on this online discussion I saw: Does Dave Concepcion belong in the HOF?
Here's his comparison to Ozzie Smith. The one glaring difference is "Wins above Replacement" which I don't totally understand or trust as a measurement. I mean, did Concepcion NOT win games "above replacement" by another shortstop because those games were won by Rose, Morgan, Perez, Bench, Foster and Griffey? It's not like the Reds didn't win a lot of games in Davey's prime -- more between 1970 and 1976 than any National League franchise in history over a six year span. How much more WAR does a shortstop need to provide? This comparison with Ozzie -- who was a first ballot HOFer with 92 percent of the vote is one thing. Compare Concepcion with someone like Phil Rizzuto. That's a glaring win in DC's favor.
DC was a player I patterned some of my techniques after as far a fielding and some of his hitting stance (Not all but some), just a Big Red Machine junky. DC was a staple and that is not a small accomplishment at that time on that team.