The big difference is this is just Reeves 2nd year at Kentucky, with Cal, and with Cal's staff and some of the same teammates.. but, this is Roaches 4th year. If you ask me, there's a lot more room for growth for Reeves in COLLEGE than there is for Roach. Reevs has had his 20+ point games, he's also had his near FORTY pt games, hes been a leader, he has experience, and again, this is only his 2nd season at an elite program.Last year, Roach averaged 13.6 PPG & 3.1 assists on 43% shooting.
Last year, Reeves averaged 14.4 PPG & 1.1 assists on 41% shooting.
Roach had more talent around him so he wasn't asked to score as much, but those numbers could have been 15-16 PPG. Roach moved to SG because a future lottery pick was playing PG, Proctor was a better distributor and the team took off when Proctor got over his freshman woes. Roach has played in a Final 4, Roach has scored 21 points in a Sweet 16 game. Roach is a former 5-star. It's definitely close, but Roach is the better college basketball player.
Reeves shoots better from 3, but that is it. However, Reeves does fit this years UK team better than Roach would, UK needs shooting from 3, not another dribble-drive playmaker like Roach is.
We've been over this, Proctor is in no way a sure fire future lottery pick. I explained to you that some mock drafts have him barely in the 1st round. There's a lot of ways to go before he's a top5 pick like some of you think.
And the end is ultimately my point, For whatever you think Roach is as a PG, this list was for SHOOTING GUARD, not GUARD. In no world is Roach a better SG, when that's not even the position he should be playing.. than Antonio Reeves, Kentucky's BEST player last year.
Edit: Roach being a 5* recruit kind of doesn't matter at this point. If you're a 5* recruit and still need 4 years of college ball, then you clearly were over ranked to some degree. Im not convinced that Roach is any better of a basketball player, or pro-prospect, than Reeves is, simply because of his ranking from 5 years ago. This isn't like comparing Reeves to a talent like Jayson Tatum.
Last edited: