ADVERTISEMENT

“OFFICIALS SUPER BOWL THREAD- BENGALS @ RAMS

Carman looks like a bad pick. Hopefully he develops, but we’ll see. He showed some flashes of being able to move people. I prefer we sign OL and draft the best play available regardless of position outside of QB and maybe WR. The Bengals have drafted well at seemingly every position besides the OL. I’d rather bring in experienced linemen.
I agree with you. Cincinnati needs proven commodities on the offensive line and then fill other areas through the draft.
 
Carman looks like a bad pick. Hopefully he develops, but we’ll see. He showed some flashes of being able to move people. I prefer we sign OL and draft the best play available regardless of position outside of QB and maybe WR. The Bengals have drafted well at seemingly every position besides the OL. I’d rather bring in experienced linemen.
I just can't understand why Carman can't beat out Prince or Adeneji
 
I know one of the games he started, can't remember which one, he played well. The game after he went out with a back problem, and it was all downhill from there.
My orange and black tinted glasses hope is that he needs more time adjusting from tackle to guard. Maybe this offseason will be big for him. Reports were he showed up to camp overweight so some red flags there on that front but time will tell. Hopefully he can be an average starter for us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pulaski Cat Fan
I'd like to sign a proven corner in free agency as well. Going to be several on the market including JC Jackson, Stephon Gilmore, and possibly Charlton Davis if TB doesn't franchise tag him which they probably will. Doubt we would spend the money for those guys but we could get a guy like Steven Nelson from Pittsburgh as TJ Watt cleaned them out. There are several others that could instantly start for us.

The more you can draft to add depth the better off you are, obviously.

Re: the Carman talk. He was a projected 3rd rounder at best (seen him projected as low as 5-6) so I was stunned when we took a guy in the 2nd round that would have been there in the 3rd or later.
 
NO! It is the exact opposite. The awful play calling CONTRIBUTED to the OL deficiency by putting Joe in obvious long passing situations on 3rd down. You guys laugh at me for harping on play action, but that is 100% of what our offense should have featured, not barely used. Especially in the red zone. The failure to use more play action 1st down passing was the biggest failure of the Bengals season including the offensive line. It was that big of a mistake.

Play action passing, max protect packages, and rolling Joe out of the pocket were just not employed properly to compensate for an awful offensive line. Instead Joe was put in shotgun in 3rd and long and asked to make something happen which got him sacked 70 times in 1 season. A god awful number that is an abomination.

BTW, I am not making up some extravagant NFL innovation, I am talking about what NE, TB, and Tom Brady won a zillion playoff games and Super Bowls doing. Brady wanted the ball out of his hands and that's how you do it.

The entire NE system is designed to control the pass rush with flair passes and the short passing game to give the QB multiple options on short routes to make the defense pay for going after your QB. The ball is out of Brady's hands in under 2 seconds. It features passing on 1st down, play action in 1st and 2nd downs, and pre snap reads by the QB. You never hold the ball as it's there or it's gone. Bill Belichick mentioned Tom had brought that NE system to TB and there was extensive press coverage about Tom going to Arians and telling him his long passing game was getting him sacked too much and that he demanded they implement that short controlled passing game based off PLAY ACTION PASSING which you guys laugh at me for harping on which I do because it was so obvious but we still failed miserably.
You may be right about that stuff, but we are clearly playing backups at RG and RT. We've got to address that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pulaski Cat Fan
Carman looks like a bad pick. Hopefully he develops, but we’ll see. He showed some flashes of being able to move people. I prefer we sign OL and draft the best play available regardless of position outside of QB and maybe WR. The Bengals have drafted well at seemingly every position besides the OL. I’d rather bring in experienced linemen.
Co-sign
 
PFF which I read a lot has the guy I want c Tyler Linderbaum going to Dallas at 24 and us taking IOL Kenyon Green from A&M. Sounds like a pretty versatile guy to bring in:

The dream scenario. The Bengals badly need offensive line help that can step in right away. The good news is that Green has shown he can start anywhere, as he logged reps at every position except center this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pulaski Cat Fan
PFF says this about Linderbaum:

Linderbaum may slide because of his size at 290 pounds, but he shouldn’t. The Cowboys would happily reinvest in their offensive line after things fell apart down the stretch last year. Linderbaum would bring Travis Frederick levels of assuredness to the position.

That's what I am hoping. If he does slide we've got to be sitting on him. No question about it.
 
PFF which I read a lot has the guy I want c Tyler Linderbaum going to Dallas at 24 and us taking IOL Kenyon Green from A&M. Sounds like a pretty versatile guy to bring in:

The dream scenario. The Bengals badly need offensive line help that can step in right away. The good news is that Green has shown he can start anywhere, as he logged reps at every position except center this season.
I listened to Tony and Mo yesterday (ESPN Cincinnati) and they were breaking down Bengal Super Bowl PFF grades. They got to OL. Isiah Prince had a TWO POINT FOUR in pass protection 😆 I think you get 3 points just for running on the field with your helmet on.
 
I listened to Tony and Mo yesterday (ESPN Cincinnati) and they were breaking down Bengal Super Bowl PFF grades. They got to OL. Isiah Prince had a TWO POINT FOUR in pass protection 😆 I think you get 3 points just for running on the field with your helmet on.
It was the worst performance by an offensive line in Super Bowl history as graded in pass block win rate. Joe was sacked 7 times in his last 22 drop backs.

Just because a qb doesn't go down immediately with injury then people think it is OK. They don't or can't understand despite the mountain of evidence and history how those hits devastate your career down the line and cut it short. Cam Newton goes from MVP to a scrub in 6 years because of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pulaski Cat Fan
It was the worst performance by an offensive line in Super Bowl history as graded in pass block win rate. Joe was sacked 7 times in his last 22 drop backs.

Just because a qb doesn't go down immediately with injury then people think it is OK. They don't or can't understand despite the mountain of evidence and history how those hits devastate your career down the line and cut it short. Cam Newton goes from MVP to a scrub in 6 years because of it.
I agree. I want us to go sign proven commodities. We need guys who can step in and hold it down RIGHT NOW. Draft for quality depth, for guys you can bring along and not rush out there. Would also like to see us snag some pass rushers for D, we need a reliable 4 WR option of someone gets hurt, etc.

I think with what we've show. This year, attracting free agents won't be hard. Go sign those OL
 
Crazy. A mock draft done a week earlier on PFF has Linderbaum going 7th to the Giants:

The Giants' interior offensive line needs help and although this isn’t a sexy pick, there hasn’t been a better center prospect in years. Linderbaum has everything the Giants could want from a center. New York had the lowest cumulative pass-blocking grade in the league from guards and centers last season (38.7), and Linderbaum would definitely help that mark improve moving forward.

The idea that it is possible for this guy to drop to us is irresistible to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pulaski Cat Fan
I listened to Tony and Mo yesterday (ESPN Cincinnati) and they were breaking down Bengal Super Bowl PFF grades. They got to OL. Isiah Prince had a TWO POINT FOUR in pass protection 😆 I think you get 3 points just for running on the field with your helmet on.
Hell far, Tayshaun Prince could provide better pass protection than that. It just absolutely friggin sucks. What's so bad is, with an average line the Bengals easily win that game. It's disheartening.
 
Crazy. A mock draft done a week earlier on PFF has Linderbaum going 7th to the Giants:

The Giants' interior offensive line needs help and although this isn’t a sexy pick, there hasn’t been a better center prospect in years. Linderbaum has everything the Giants could want from a center. New York had the lowest cumulative pass-blocking grade in the league from guards and centers last season (38.7), and Linderbaum would definitely help that mark improve moving forward.

The idea that it is possible for this guy to drop to us is irresistible to me.
I'd love to have Linderbaum. I'd really love to have drafted Creed Humphrey this last draft, and passed on Carman. We would have an upgrade all year this season and could go with another position this draft.
 
The first possession where Burrow didn’t throw to a wide open Higgins on 4th & 1 was costly. Knew it wasn’t gonna be our night.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cleisthenes
The first possession where Burrow didn’t throw to a wide open Higgins on 4th & 1 was costly. Knew it wasn’t gonna be our night.
Joe missed a lot of guys out there that were running open. He's going to feel awful when they show him the film. Can't blame Joe after being sacked 70 times. I just hope this is something that he gets over this offseason, but he definitely was suffering from PTSD (Post Traumatic Sack Disorder).

I think Joe's natural instinct because it served him so well his whole life prior to the NFL is always to tuck and duck in a spinning move to get away and it causes him to pull it down. Must get over that. The hardest thing to transition to in the NFL is not just how fast everything is, but also standing in there and delivering the ball just as you're hit, not tucking it down instead. He stands in there then he's got a lot of big throws he could have made. On the last series alone he got rid of the ball too quickly on the 2nd and 1 go route with 2 receivers running wide open in the middle and nobody near him to pressure him, and on 4th and 1 he has a shot at a 1 yard completion but pulls it back and then of course gets sacked doing his Julius Randle spin move. Got to deliver the ball to the bitter end. Think of how many great throws that were made just as the QB was getting hit. Nobody remembers the QB pulling it down instead. Stand in there and throw the damn ball.
 
Last edited:
Yeah there are several AFC teams that are lined up to be there the next few years

If my Titans had any balls (they don't) and upgraded the QB position that is our biggest/only real weakness as well, other than ridiculous injuries. I think the Titans & UK basketball have the same strength and conditioning staff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pulaski Cat Fan
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT