I think you are right Idacat. I clearly have not read enough Tolstoy, and have misunderstood his position on this. He seems to believe in the teachings of Christianity, the Sermon on the Mount, but not in the deity of Jesus. Not unlike Benjamin Franklin. Would you agree? I will continue to learn more about Tolstoy's position on this, but I think I stand corrected.Originally posted by IdaCat:
Your credibility is shot dude. I too like some of the Sermon on the Mount, but I'm not going to do a Jeffersonian style Bible rewrite, cutting out the bullshit like Tolstoy did. Also, I don't have time to check every Russian you pull out of your ass for whatever dumb point you're trying to make. Give it up. You suck at history.
Thank you for admitting a mistake. We all make them. FTR, I didn't know these details until I looked it up. I guess we've both learned something.Originally posted by wkycatfan:
I think you are right Idacat. I clearly have not read enough Tolstoy, and have misunderstood his position on this. He seems to believe in the teachings of Christianity, the Sermon on the Mount, but not in the deity of Jesus. Not unlike Benjamin Franklin. Would you agree? I will continue to learn more about Tolstoy's position on this, but I think I stand corrected.Originally posted by IdaCat:
Your credibility is shot dude. I too like some of the Sermon on the Mount, but I'm not going to do a Jeffersonian style Bible rewrite, cutting out the bullshit like Tolstoy did. Also, I don't have time to check every Russian you pull out of your ass for whatever dumb point you're trying to make. Give it up. You suck at history.
Fair enough.Originally posted by wkycatfan:
I thought we were talking giving to the poor......
Not what I said. I was trying to say that Jesus point on the sermon on the mount was that WE should as individuals, but He wasn't talking about the government doing it. Jesus said render unto Caesar, that which is Caesar's. It seems open ended at that point.Originally posted by Willy4UK:
You mentioned that government shouldn't give to the poor (Which I do agree by the way, although there are cases where financial assistance is a must- But I hate for the gov't to do it due to "learned helplessness"). But were you implying that Jesus didn't want us to rely on the gov't? Was there an uprising of tax payers around of the 1st of century who were making societal protests about their tax money going to support the poors? When Jesus got up on that Mount, was his sermon in the interest of working tax payers?