Any coach you get is going to be a risk. There is no automatic slam dunk hire…hiring coaches is a total crap shoot. While Frost and Napier (debateable) are examples of G5 guys that failed, Drinkwitz and Heupel are examples of guys from G5 who have succeeded. Any route you go (Coordinator, G5, current P4) have success stories and failures.
In the past 30 years, UK has hired a current P4 coach (Curry), FCS coach (Mumme), position coach (Morris), former P4 coach turned NFL coach (Brooks), internal coordinator (Joker) and external coordinator (Stoops). Some have worked to an extent, others have failed miserably.
With Sumrall…is it a risk…of course. All hires are. Does he have characteristics that coaches need to be successful…yes. He was the best recruiter on staff when he was here. Players love him. He has charisma to work with donors on NIL.
Is he the perfect candidate? No
Is he worth taking a shot on knowing he’s a UK grad and former coach that could build this into something long term if he succeeds? I would say yes.
Doesn’t mean I’m not open to other possibilities. If there is a better candidate that UK has a shot at, go for it. I’m just not sure who that is.