If true shame on Coach Brooks. UK could do better.
For all of barnhart's piousness and griping about NIL it's first few years and kids leaving in the portal, he's always been okay with the adults pushing out kids. He let his guy mingione wipe out nearly the entire baseball team one off season in the first year of the portal to take a stab at saving his job, which he was able to do.We don’t know the whole story yet. I agree it doesn’t sound like a Kenny Brooks or a Mitch to force a player out.
That's what I've been kinda hearing too. Kinda losing just a smidge of respect for Brooks on that. If a player wants to stay for their SENIOR year, even if its as a walk on, you let them stay.
This is the harsh reality of a new coach, the portal and NIL. It’s a business. A new coach needs players that fit his system. You have to take emotions out of it.
E Everyone agrees but only to an extent. There are 15 scholarships. She is a sr thats off the books next year regardless.
Maaaayyyybe if we had 14 scholarships used up and a game changer wanted to commit. Otherwise there is zero reason to push out a sr. Especially an in state sr.
Sadly this is the world of college basketball. She wasn’t his recruit and he was hired to pull a program out of ruins. I am sure she wasnt content to practice and not play. Coaching changes are always hard on returning players unless you are a star. They want to build their team. It happens everywhere. She should go play for Eastern or Morehead or maybe even Pikeville college near home if she wants to keep playing otherwise get a degree and enjoy life without basketball. It is a fleeting journey any way.If true shame on Coach Brooks. UK could do better.
He most certainly did. He gutted the roster when he first got here. He also didn’t recruit many KY kids. Fact is, Rowe was a KE recruit not KB. She probably never gets recruited if KB is coaching here for her HS seasons.Pretty crappy move especially by a new coach
Why doesn't his boss step in?
Even ccc didn't pull this stunt
She has been committed to UK since she was a freshman in high school, so she is actually a MM recruit.Fact is, Rowe was a KE recruit not KB. She probably never gets recruited if KB is coaching here for her HS seasons.
KE was MM main recruiter. She may not have been HC but she very much recruited her.She has been committed to UK since she was a freshman in high school, so she is actually a MM recruit.
It doesn't matter. I'm going to give the credit to Mitchell though. You can give the credit to people like Vince Marrow in football because the roster is so big, but in basketball, the head coach always has to seal the deal.KE was MM main recruiter. She may not have been HC but she very much recruited her.
Her minutes were down this year, and it was easy to see why- there were better players on the team. People understood it and I heard no one being angry. I really hate the idea of EVER pushing out a player going into their senior year. She played three years and you've deprived her the opportunity to play for her entire college career here. She was denied the opportunity to go through senior night. Kenny Brooks screwed up here. Plain and simple.KB was probably in a no win situation. People are angry he asked her to transfer. Let’s change the situation. Let’s say he keeps her and she doesn’t play. People are mad she isn’t playing and question why did he keep her if she wasn’t going to play while saying things like he should have told her she wasn’t going to play so she could’ve transferred.
Unfortunately, as head coach he has to make these hard decisions as his job is determined by wins and losses. KB feels another player gives him a better chance to do that. This is big girl basketball. If people don’t like things like this, we should’ve kept Kyra Elzy.
Sadly this is the world of college basketball. She wasn’t his recruit and he was hired to pull a program out of ruins. I am sure she wasnt content to practice and not play. Coaching changes are always hard on returning players unless you are a star. They want to build their team. It happens everywhere. She should go play for Eastern or Morehead or maybe even Pikeville college near home if she wants to keep playing otherwise get a degree and enjoy life without basketball. It is a fleeting journey any way.
It happens in every program. Cal did it. Stoops has done it. Mingione did it. Craig Skinner has done it. Dawn Staley and Kim Mulkey has done it. That’s who you want to compete against. If you want to be a big time program, you have to do things like this. If you don’t, then we should’ve kept Kyra Elzy.Her minutes were down this year, and it was easy to see why- there were better players on the team. People understood it and I heard no one being angry. I really hate the idea of EVER pushing out a player going into their senior year. She played three years and you've deprived her the opportunity to play for her entire college career here. She was denied the opportunity to go through senior night. Kenny Brooks screwed up here. Plain and simple.
She’s essentially given up her scholarship. I’d imagine if she could walk on she would.I don’t think any of us know how many scholarship players we have for next year. If she really wanted to stay she could have agreed to give up her scholarship and be a walk-on.
If your 15th roster spot is determining your wins and losses regularly you’ve got major problems.KB was probably in a no win situation. People are angry he asked her to transfer. Let’s change the situation. Let’s say he keeps her and she doesn’t play. People are mad she isn’t playing and question why did he keep her if she wasn’t going to play while saying things like he should have told her she wasn’t going to play so she could’ve transferred.
Unfortunately, as head coach he has to make these hard decisions as his job is determined by wins and losses. KB feels another player gives him a better chance to do that. This is big girl basketball. If people don’t like things like this, we should’ve kept Kyra Elzy.
She's staying at Kentucky and working on her degree. She made a post saying her long term plan is to become a Physical Therapist at UK.Is there any proof that Brooks asked her to leave?
She’s essentially given up her scholarship. I’d imagine if she could walk on she would.
If your 15th roster spot is determining your wins and losses regularly you’ve got major problems.
She made a social media post today saying she's off the team but not transferring. She's going to finish her Education at Kentucky.Did she really want to do that? No one knows except her, her family, and the team.
Did she want to be the 15th man AND give up a scholly in the same year? She would be THAT girl on the team.
I think folks are confused:
1. Being pushed off of the team straight away
2. Not liking the options presented to you, being reminded that you could transfer and then deciding to leave.
These are not the same.
If the rest of the team has a problem with her, then it's up to the coach to say, "I'm sorry, I can't allow this to continue and be a distraction." That would be one of the only things that makes sense in this situation. She's not a star player, so it would be easier to sacrifice her than to sacrifice team chemistry.She’s essentially given up her scholarship. I’d imagine if she could walk on she would.
That’s because she made the decision to stay at the university. He was being upfront about the situation so she could get out and front to transfer to another school so she could play for her senior year. She chose not to so she couple stay in the UK PT program.People keep saying "Kenny probably told he she wouldn't play if she stayed." SHE IS STAYING AT THE COLLEGE. It's pretty clear what happened.
I know 130k sounds good in Kentucky, but is it really that much in California?It says she won't be entering the portal in the post.
My brother makes somewhere around 130K in Sacramento as a DPT. She won't be hurting for money. Hell, she'll probably make more than most WNBA players.
Best wishes to her.
Three years of not being wanted around even under a coaching change seems far fetched.If the rest of the team has a problem with her, then it's up to the coach to say, "I'm sorry, I can't allow this to continue and be a distraction." That would be one of the only things that makes sense in this situation. She's not a star player, so it would be easier to sacrifice her than to sacrifice team chemistry.
These hypotheticals of her walking-on and being a manager are based on the assumption that she is even wanted around on a daily basis by coaches and teammates. Is she? We don't know.
Let’s do this. It’s Noah’s senior year. And Pope says transfer or be off the team. You don’t think that would be a dumb as hell PR move?No one would care if she wasn’t from KY. Being from KY doesn’t entitle her to anything. She had a year to prove that she warrants a spot on the roster and the coaches don’t think she did. If we are being honest, many new coaches would’ve let her go last year. Brooks at least gave her an opportunity. This isn’t junior basketball where everyone gets a trophy.
It reads like you're agreeing with my point.That’s because she made the decision to stay at the university. He was being upfront about the situation so she could get out and front to transfer to another school so she could play for her senior year. She chose not to so she couple stay in the UK PT program.
If your 15th roster spot is determining your wins and losses regularly you’ve got major problems.
Respectfully, This wouldn't make any sense.Total PR disaster. A lot of it is the vagueness of her social media post. But I wonder if it’s a situation where she asked if there would be playing time for her and was told no. Then was told if she wanted to see the court, she’d need to transfer. Then rather putting in all the work on top of school, she decided it was best not to play. He may have told her she could stay on the team but she chose not to ride the pine.
I had a player ask what they could do to see floor time and told him he needed to work on his body to get stronger and get in better shape. He told his parents I said if he was fat and if he didn’t drop 20lbs he couldn’t play. Thank God they didn’t go to social media and pop off before talking to me and letting me explain.