Should have never bought the “have to modernize the offense” narrative. Now we are exactly what our recruiting ranks say we are and we will never out recruit the traditional powers in the south.
Run heavy, ball control, RP0. It isn’t sexy but it’s effective and easier to recruit big boys up front to run block and a couple stout athletes and speed to pound the ball.
You saw GT “modernize” and go from a consistent top 25 team to bottom feeder bc they can’t out recruit all the SEC schools in their backyard. You saw the military academies start to go away from it and all have a serious drop in performance as well. Army went back to triple option today bc they weren’t scoring enough so far this season in their “modern balanced O” and dominated Time of Possession and beat a very good Coastal Carolina team that can light the scoreboard up.
There is a reason our best seasons came with ball control and Big Blue Wall domination. There is a reason nobody could stop Lynn Bowden even though they knew it was coming and had we switch to him after Sawyer Smiths injury we likely add 2 more wins that year. There is a reason one of the few wins against UT in 30 years came with a WR at QB where we ran the most basic option scheme ever.
“Balanced” isn’t going to work “to take the next step” unless you can recruit an NFL JV roster 3 deep. You either have to commit to super spread offense playing as fast as possible and try to out score but be ok w the occasional 60-7 beat down. Or you go try to win games under 30 and control the ball. Those systems allow you to play above your team talent level and have a punchers chance against the big dogs. My preference is RPO ball control bc it’s more consistent and I’ll take being a ranked 10-25 team yearly