Once again, Grand Padre is taking his woke ass takes in here and trying to be the white Knight. But little does he know that your boy White Wayne received a baseball encyclopedia for his 10th birthday and knows the history of the game better than anyone other than the baseball card guy.
I’m not saying racism didn’t exist, but Aaron played in an absolute stacked time. And this was at a time when they cared a lot more about batting average than they do now. Secondly, pitchers were often included in the MVP voting and often won over Aaron.
So take a few years where a black guy or minority won or Aaron’s numbers are sick.
1954:Willie Mays won.
1956: Campanella won
1956: Aaron finished 3rd. The winner was Don Newcombe who went 27-7
1957: Hank Aaron won
1958: Aaron finished 3rd. The winner, Ernie Banks. Second was Willy Mays.
1959; Aaron finished 3rd. Ernie Banks won again.
1961: Aaron finished 11th. Frank Robinson won.
1962: Maury Willis and Willy Mays finished first and second
1963: Sandy Koufax won, but Dick Groat beat out Aaron for second. Aaron had a much better year than Groat unless he was word class at D or something. EDIT: Groat’s team won the WS while Aaron’s team finished 6th in the NL.
1965: Willy Mays won
1966: Clemente
1967: Cepeda
1968: Bob Gibson
1969: Willy McCovey
1971: Aaron’s last monster year. Here’s an interesting one. Joe Torre hit .364, had 230 hits, and had 137 RBI (all led the league) as a catcher and won the MVP, but the next seven guys in order were black. Aaron had a great year and finished 3rd.
When I was a kid I would try to put together the best single season lineup from each position in history. I tried my best to put Aaron on the team, but while he was consistent as hell, he never hit over 50 HR’s and never had a year like Ted Williams where his average was through the roof. Aaron would have benefited heavily in the MVP race had they had advanced statistics though.
By the way, Eddie Matthews is a guy who got screwed in the MVP race more than anybody. Look at his WAR by season and then compare how he did in the MVP votes.