One of the perks from working from home the past couple weeks is I'm able to listen to 2-3 complete shows per day instead of just bits and pieces like usual, or the Dick's Picks I've got loaded onto the iPod in my car and nearly gotten burned out on from so many listens. About 15 years ago when I got hardcore into the Dead and started seeing the post-Garcia bands religiously, I downloaded about every 5-star show from Archive.org I could get my hands on before things changed and they only allowed you to stream, and not download, the soundboards.
There was a particular reviewer who was very thorough and knowledgeable who went by the name "Dr. Flashback," and I made sure to nab every show I could that he gave a 5-star review to. I was still getting my feet wet in the vast Grateful Dead pool at the time. Come to find out, the guy is from Lexington and is a big UK fan. But he knew his shit and that info was valuable to me and a lot of others.
Anyway, several years ago, I asked him for his top 10 shows from 1969-74 and this is what he gave me. Might be beneficial for someone who's new to the band and wanting to delve further. These were an interesting 5 years for the Dead. The acid-fueled shows were largely coming to an end by 1969 and the Crosby, Stills and Nash influence kicked in, as evidenced by Workingman's Dead and American Beauty. Robert Hunter was churning out classic after classic by 1970 and Weir's old pal, John Barlow joined forces not long after to help form another epic songwriting partnership.
Europe 72 might be the best tour the band ever did. Pretty much every show reached legendary status. Keith Godchaux had joined the band in 1971 and Pigpen was slowly getting phased out. The newer material was getting too complicated for him. The transition into 73-74 saw a lot of jazz influence starting to appear in live shows. So, in just 3-4 years the band had done a complete 180.
Anyway, here's the list. A lot of these are probably complete shows on Youtube as well.
1969
1/26/69
2/22/69
2/28/69
3/1/69
4/5/69
4/21/69
4/22/69
5/24/69
11/8/69
12/30/69
1970 - speculative, so much is unknown.
1/2/70
1/23/70
2/11/70
2/13/70
5/2/70
5/15/70
9/19/70
9/20/70
10/31/70
11/8/70
1971
2/19/71
4/5/71
4/28/71
4/21/71
7/2/71
11/7/71
12/6/71
12/10/71
12/14/71
12/31/71
1972
4/8/72
4/14/72
5/11/72
5/26/72
7/26/72
8/24/72
8/27/72
9/17/72
9/21/72
12/31/72
1973
2/15/73
3/28/73
5/26/73
6/10/73
10/30/73
11/11/73
11/17/73
11/21/73
12/2/73
12/6/73
1974
2/24/74
5/17/74
5/21/74
6/16/74
6/18/74
6/26/74
7/31/74
8/6/74
9/18/74
10/17/74