I wouldn’t suggest that anyone spend $40k/semester unless you’re from a rich family with money to burn. Honestly, a lot of what you suggest sounds like what community college offers - a skill with very little fluff.Agree with a lot of your post. But, well-rounded is so subjective. And should colleges force 'well-roundedness' on every student? What about the student that just wants to fiddle with computers and doesn't give a damn about Sociology or Music Appreciation or Intro to Business? Is the $40+k spend each semester at some of these schools the correct price for being forced to 'learn' crap you care nothing about and will never remember? Shouldn't that student be allowed to just study what he or she wants?
Instead of loading college students up with 'bunny' courses that they only take for the grade and quickly forget anything 'learned', why not require courses that may be applicable to real-life - personal finance, basic carpentry/electrical/plumbing/drywall installation/etc., debate/discourse/negotiation/communication, basic 'home' IT skills (to protect your data, to install a new HD, etc.), and others? How many universities have added dozens of employees in DEI who do what, exactly? Professors that have to publish-or-perish and/or whore for grant money (which DOGE has revealed that there is a great deal of cash for absolute nonsense 'studies') - are they spending much time in the classroom actually teaching? Many professors that I've known teach maybe two classes a semester and many have TAs do their grading. They spend a lot more time on research and fund raising than actually teaching.
From what I've heard from multiple parents whose kid went to an Ivy League school, all the hotshot professors with distinguished honors basically only teach grad students. So, your little Johnny or Susie is spending $85k/year to be taught by a TA or associate professor at Harvard. Hard for me to believe that's worth the money.
I agree, most distinguished professors teach grad students. They are there to bring in research grants. Their grad students help do the research to keep the money flowing. Most undergraduate classes don’t really require a world class individual to present the information. You just need someone that has mastered the material.