If we're talking combination of on the court contribution and personality, I'm going with Ulis, Towns or Wall.
So then Doron Lamb > Jamal Mashburn?
Marquis Teague > Tayshaun Prince?
This seems like a silly take on the surface.
I sort of miss them all, and fondly remember them equally. Cal has always recruited not only the top athletes, but really quality people. So I'll change the direction of this and offer one of my favorite moments ......I laugh every time.
I like it! I was so mad watching that game at work. After that I ran round like omg I cant believe this lol.
Unfortunately towns is on a team nobody wants to talk about for obvious reasons. Finish and he could've been better than Davis at UK. Boogie and wall kicked it off, something they didn't have to do. Towns was on a team that was uber talented that disappointingly didn't finish. I'd put him 4th on the list though
1. Anthony Davis
2. KAT
3. Boogie
4. Wall
5. Sleeper Pick (Terrence Jones)
Like a few others have mentioned, the first logical answer is Anthony Davis. He definitely would have had the most impact (changed history of the program) if he had stayed for four years. We likely end up with at least one more if not more titles. No one impacted the game more, so he has to be my first choice.
The emotional choice is John Wall. In my opinion, no other player has had his charisma and confidence. He definitely brought excitement to the program. From the moment he was lowered to the stage on midnight madness doing the "John Wall" you knew he was a star.
There was a lot of brotherhood in that moment which is what Cal is all about. And some pretty sloppy tackling JWI was euphoric after that. I KNEW they were gonna win at that point. One of the funnest moments in UK history
As you can tell by my name both Fox and Monk are high on my list. I could never imagine missing a player more than Wall and Cousins but there was something I really liked about the way those two played. I of course would have loved Davis and MKG for four years but those four really stand out for me.
MKG. You don't find that grit heart and leadership very often. Nothing wrong picking Davis at #1.. his ability on the college level is absolutely silly. But I like what MKG brought on a team-level.
Liggins did not get recruited by him, but he was a Cal era guy. I loved watching him play D and hit those crucial jumpers. Played with that fire every team needs.
Tyler Ulis and
Arthony Davis