Bolden transferring from Duke.
- Thread starter ~Keyser Soze~
- Start date
This is the Duke lineup I was referring to which is much better than what you listed for us:
Duval - Top 3 player and the best PG in the class without question.
Allen/Kennard
Gary Trent Jr 5*, #13 in nation
Bamba - Top defensive big in class
Carter - Very good big ranked the same as Bamba in the top 10
As of today:
Duval > Green
Kennard > Diallo (without playing yet many would most likely have a Sr. Allen, at the least, equal)
Trent > JV (would love to see JV do very well, Trent is a baller)
Carter > PJ
Bamba > Richards (by a long way)
Duke has no bench but if Jackson returns that would be big for them.
I don't really agree with the comparison. You are breaking it down a little too lightly and that looks like the most optimistic for Duke line-up and match up favorable to them. While worst for UK.
I get the worry that DUke *could* land all these guys.. but seriously.. what are the odds, especially when Bamba is still a UK lean and I'm hearing Knox to UNC?
The odds that no one else leaves for Duke and they get Duval, Bamba, Knox? Highly doubtful.
The odds that no one else leaves for Duke and they get Duval, Bamba, Knox? Highly doubtful.
I think you are missing out on part of the conversation...
The initial post stated that "IF" Duval and Bamba chose Duke they would have the best starting 5...
That said, I believe Bamba is going to UK and that Duval is 50-50 in terms of even qualifying (absolute joke that he could for Duke).
i understood that.
But what i was saying was in regards other things. Are we sure that Humphries and SKJ won't get better? Kennard would be 3 in that roster since he is the biggest of the guards. He would not match up well against Vanderbilt, and Diallo would be better than Trent.
I also think Green would be better fit now to run the team than Duval. While, Duval would be more fantastic and exciting to watch. I would assume he would defend better too. However, i would expect Green to have higher assist number and engagement of the team. Duval would have better career in NBA as well. But, there is something about running the team, and i think Green is better suited for that now.
Bamba would kill anyone on our team next year. So i don't disagree there.
1. Equal (Duval versus Green)
2. Diallo
3. Equal (Kennard versus Vanderbilt / PJ Washington)
4. UK (SKJ/WG versus Carter)
5. Bamba (Duke) (Humphries/Richards/Tai versus Bamba)
And we still haven;t heard about Allen, Kennard or Jackson.. these were the players Duke thought they could lose.. while still retaining Jeter, Bolden, Giles, and Obi.
Duke is 0/4 so far.. and I don't think they are done losing players.
Weird feeling surrounding Duke right now.. Seems recruits are buying their BS, yet the players are all jumping ship. Cal has ONLY had guys transfer who knew they had to go elsewhere to obtain minutes. Guys like Wiltjer, Matthews and Lee. Two of those guys got a lot of PT here.. it just go to the point that they did all they could. And if I recall, not one had anything bad to say about Kentucky/Cal.
Meanwhile, Duke is shedding players left and right and not on good terms.
Duke is 0/4 so far.. and I don't think they are done losing players.
Weird feeling surrounding Duke right now.. Seems recruits are buying their BS, yet the players are all jumping ship. Cal has ONLY had guys transfer who knew they had to go elsewhere to obtain minutes. Guys like Wiltjer, Matthews and Lee. Two of those guys got a lot of PT here.. it just go to the point that they did all they could. And if I recall, not one had anything bad to say about Kentucky/Cal.
Meanwhile, Duke is shedding players left and right and not on good terms.
This isnt about fit for UK is was best starting 5 as a squad.
Nor was depth ever a criteria.
But I will add my comments to your 5:
1. Equal (Duval versus Green) Again, not about "fit" Duval is extremely talented and larger than Quade - even Bamba just this week stated he is the best passer and point guard in the class.
2. Diallo Diallo > Trent - dont disagree
3. Equal (Kennard versus Vanderbilt / PJ Washington) Maybe, but Kennard is a proven player - JV is not a shooter and PJ will be interesting - not sure they both play the 3 but would hope the tandem would be better than just Kennard.
4. UK (SKJ/WG versus Carter) You obviously havent seen Carter, hell you must not of seen SKJ/WG either. The way our 2 guys played this year, its not even close.
5. Bamba (Duke) (Humphries/Richards/Tai versus Bamba)[/QUOTE]
I should have added I am glad we have Green, he is a much better fit and he is qualified.
As stated before I think we get Bamba.
I forgot about Trent. I don't agree about Kennard over Diallo. Carter is very good but he wants to be a wing. He doesn't want to bang down low with PJ/Richards/Gabriel/SKJ. I really think Richards is gonna surprise folks, but Bamba is really, really good.
I don't think it's as overwhelming in favor of duke as some. UK's bench is a definite advantage though.
Cal calling out Bilas was my favorite thing so far. Busted him bigtime on national TV. Suck it Jay. The usual suspects have had to eat their pens because they can't say anything about UK and Cal because their idol fell and fell to a lowly SEC team of all things. Must be infuriating for them. All those articles they had ready after duke won that awesome ACCT. Which king idiot Bilas said was harder than winning the FF.but there is NO media bias towards UK and Cal, at all, right?
![[winking]](http://l.yimg.com/j/assets/img/emoticons/classic/wink.r191677.gif "Winking [winking]")
That's the first song that popped into my head, but that's not the right one. He only says "Hello it's me", he doesn't say "again".
If Diallo produces on Kennard's level we will be in good shape.
Carter is better than Richards/Gabriel/SKJ and PJ is only 6'7. Gabriel became useless and was a negative, SKJ couldn't even get in a game to even be a negative..
I hope Richards does surprise us.
I think the Duval/Bamba scenario is a large advantage as to starting 5, and yes, Duke has no bench assuming Jackson leaves.
I would love to see Bamba here and WG come around, and I liked SKJ's offense, hopefully it starts to click for him.
We are not sure exactly what we have yet in JV and PJ, but they both have great potential.
I'm not trading places with Duke today.
I like my team...
Need more shooters...
Last edited:
Diallo is the X factor IMO. If he has a consistent shot and can defend, UK has a guy that nobody else in college basketball will have. A bigger version of Monk. UK will have size down low and a legit rim protector with Richards who is a true 5. Don't think rebounding and straight line layups will be a problem next year. Gonna be interesting.
Washington and Vanderbilt will make the majority forget about Knox next season. We have the wings we need
We will see.
Neither are the offensive threat that Knox is.
They have talent and grit, I'm sure we will love them.
If Bolden leaves and they add Bamba, they basically have two that can man the 5. Bamba and Carter split time there.
K plays a stretch 4, usually a big SF. Parker, Winslow, Ingram, and Tatum over the last four years. When he has played two bigs together it hasn't ended well, especially if the bigs couldn't shoot the jumper. I don't think Bamba and/or Carter can shoot that well. Can't see them playing together.
I think K is tired of Allen's "issues" and the bad press it gets him. He is going to send him packing.
He is going to sign Duval.
Kennard decides to stay (rich kid doesn't need the NBA).
He signs Knox to replace Tatum.
Bamba announces for UK, K talks Bolden into returning.
They'll lineup:
G Duval
G Jackson
G Kennard
F Knox
F Carter
Bench: Trent and Bolden.
K plays a stretch 4, usually a big SF. Parker, Winslow, Ingram, and Tatum over the last four years. When he has played two bigs together it hasn't ended well, especially if the bigs couldn't shoot the jumper. I don't think Bamba and/or Carter can shoot that well. Can't see them playing together.
I think K is tired of Allen's "issues" and the bad press it gets him. He is going to send him packing.
He is going to sign Duval.
Kennard decides to stay (rich kid doesn't need the NBA).
He signs Knox to replace Tatum.
Bamba announces for UK, K talks Bolden into returning.
They'll lineup:
G Duval
G Jackson
G Kennard
F Knox
F Carter
Bench: Trent and Bolden.
Think Allen and Kennard are gone, knox is ours or UNC, Bolden transfers and Duval goes Arizona.
We get Bamba and puke can eat a bag of dicks
Gary Trent Jr. is better than Hami Diallo and Wendell Carter Jr. is HS National Player of the Year aka he's better than PJ/Vandy/Richards.
If Allen or Kennard comes and Duval picks Duke, then we will be the Preseason #1 again.
Duval
Allen
Trent Jr.
Knox
Carter
Bench: Jackson, DeLaurier, Jack White and Vrankovic
If Allen or Kennard comes and Duval picks Duke, then we will be the Preseason #1 again.
Duval
Allen
Trent Jr.
Knox
Carter
Bench: Jackson, DeLaurier, Jack White and Vrankovic
Scout, Rivals and 24/7 have Diallo ahead of Trent btw, but we should just take your word for it.
Sure you could be #1 again preseason, just like this year.
Knox is not yours yet and that lineup has no rim protection. Thanks though..
Honest to God, this scenario is far more likely than Duke returning all the rest AND getting the last big 3 recruits..
There's a good chance Duke is going to lose one of: Jackson/Kennard/Allen.. heck, it may even be two of them.
And I really only see them getting Knox. They paved the way for him.
Ah, you're back. Took a while to get over the beatdown by a 3rd place SEC team huh?
Amazed Duke fans are coming around.. Figured they'd still be celebrating 40-0.
At the end of the day, Duke has received zero forms of good news.. and about 4 pieces of bad news. Something is up with that program, with now THREE transfers in one year (Didn't we blast our Women's program for a similar exodus?)..
We should not assume they are going to retain the rest and add Knox/Duval/Bamba.. that doesn't happen when 4 players jump ship in the manner in which they did.
We should not assume they are going to retain the rest and add Knox/Duval/Bamba.. that doesn't happen when 4 players jump ship in the manner in which they did.
Also, what good is comparing 3 Duke Shooting Guards to Diallo? Only 40 minutes to go around. Trent might not even be a factor is Kennard stays.
Also, lol at getting Duval with Jackson still on the roster. When Kentucky does a two-guard lineup.. we can move one of them to SG.. How's that going to work with Kennard/Allen/Trent at the #2.
Face it, something has to give. You're too top heavy in some positions..
Also, lol at getting Duval with Jackson still on the roster. When Kentucky does a two-guard lineup.. we can move one of them to SG.. How's that going to work with Kennard/Allen/Trent at the #2.
Face it, something has to give. You're too top heavy in some positions..
As of today, not sure how that can be debated until we see HD and Trent play a college game.
I hope you are on to something.
I would hate to see K leave the game with a little whimper...
If Duke fans think Tatum was a black hole with the basketball, wait until they meet Carter and Trent, Jr. Carter is a 6-10" beast who thinks he is the next Magic Johnson - likes to roam the perimeter and chuck up threes too much right now. Trent never met a shot he didn't like. The team would actually probably be better off if Allen and Kennard do not come back if they get Knox.
Duke is hanging their entire hopes for next year however on landing Duval, because they know how desperately they need a PG, but talk about making a deal with the devil.
Duval is a superb talent, but he has a rep as me-first player who doesn't always play team ball, who makes the spectacular pass and often turnover instead of the easy play, and is making no bones about the fact he's just looking for the place that will give him the biggest stage next year before his leap to the NBA.
Coach K's ego and Duval's ego just sound like a recipe for disaster to me. K is a Knight disciple after all, and his in your face, screaming, coaching style just doesn't seem a good fit for a kid like Duval.
I'm not saying there's 100% something there.. but it certainly doesn't feel right. 3 players jumped ship (Giles being 4th).. on HOF Coach K? If he's sooo good, and they are soooo set for life.. what gives?
Just look at this past year.. Allen's bullshit, Coach K bails, the freshman enjoy time sitting on the bench in suits soaking it in while Kennard has to carry the team.. None of that equates to a positive atmosphere.
Just look at this past year.. Allen's bullshit, Coach K bails, the freshman enjoy time sitting on the bench in suits soaking it in while Kennard has to carry the team.. None of that equates to a positive atmosphere.
Wasn't everyone on Duke's roster this year supposed to be better than everybody on UK's roster? How'd that work out?
Wasn't Duke 2017 supposed to he >> UK 2015? Again, how'd that work out?
I sense back trouble for K in 2018.
Similar threads
