Benny Draft Prediction?
- Thread starter gocats_yay
- Start date
Agreed. He could sneak in to rd 2 if he has a good combine, but more than likely a 3-5th rd type guy.
I think it depends on his combine. If he runs the 40 under 4.6 2-3, if it's over 4.75 it will be late. He needs to get with one of those speed trainers and work on his starts, his running technique and looser those hamstrings up.
Here is Walterfootball's current projection. He is very open that he doesn't really start to evaluate guys until after the season.
http://walterfootball.com/draft2019RB.php
http://walterfootball.com/draft2019RB.php
Walter also has:
-Allen as a 1st rd pick.
-Edwards 3-4th
-Baity as a 4-6th
Of course, once again, Walter is open about being very inaccurate this time of yr.
-Allen as a 1st rd pick.
-Edwards 3-4th
-Baity as a 4-6th
Of course, once again, Walter is open about being very inaccurate this time of yr.
A 3-5 round pick at RB will more than likely make the roster. The way the league has went to a passing league they don’t value RBs the way they used to. Unless it is a special player most RBs are drafter 3rd or 4th round. Especially if it’s a team need. A 3rd round back a lot of times is a projected starter. Worst case they’ll be a backup with touches almost every game. The league just values throwing QBs, QB protectors, pass catchers and lock down corners with their first couple picks. That’s just the way the league rolls these days. But a second day back more times then not will make the roster.
It's hard to tell.
Bo Scarborough often looked unreal in college, is a click or two faster than Benny and almost went undrafted.
Bo Scarborough often looked unreal in college, is a click or two faster than Benny and almost went undrafted.
Snell's long suit is durability and YAC. Those are huge factors to NFL teams that play a grueling 16 game season with only one bye week, plus playoffs if they get there.
There may be faster and "prettier" backs out there but the way they might hold up is always a question.
AS an aside, I hear some people saying he doesn't catch the ball. He hasn't had the ball thrown to him much but the times he has he has made the catch so I'm not sure that criticism stands up.
There may be faster and "prettier" backs out there but the way they might hold up is always a question.
AS an aside, I hear some people saying he doesn't catch the ball. He hasn't had the ball thrown to him much but the times he has he has made the catch so I'm not sure that criticism stands up.
Last edited:
I have a friend who is a Seahawks fan say that they were eyeing Baity for a 3rd round pick. And ASoB had an article a few weeks back that Baity was getting some 1st round buzz. He could really help him self with a good combine showing.
Snell is Top 10 all time UK guy, but if he can't endure a college season, how is he going to last in pro game ?
I agree. Benny has shown this season that he can catch the ball, which along with his YAC numbers should make him more valuable in the draft.
Like someone said above, if he can run a 4.6 or better at the combine and show in individual workouts that he can catch the football, he should go in the 3rd round easy and maybe sneak into the 2nd.
I'm afraid Benny not being able to showcase himself in the passing game, due to our offense not really having a passing game, will hurt him.
10-15 years ago, the ground it out back like Benny was a lot more valuable. Now with the way the game has evolved RBs have lost value generally speaking, and RBs that are strictly RBs as opposed to utility/pass catching RBs have lost even more value.
Boom was a pretty solid back, went undrafted, and is now in the CFL. Was that because he should have come back for his senior, padded his stats and solidified a better draft projection? Or, was it because of the devaluation of RBs?
The league really has more RBs than it needs this day and age. Teams can throw just about anyone behind the QB and be alright.
The list of RBs on the past 10-15 or so SB winning squads is pretty ho-hum. Good players, sure, but you sure as shit can't name them off the top of your head.
10-15 years ago, the ground it out back like Benny was a lot more valuable. Now with the way the game has evolved RBs have lost value generally speaking, and RBs that are strictly RBs as opposed to utility/pass catching RBs have lost even more value.
Boom was a pretty solid back, went undrafted, and is now in the CFL. Was that because he should have come back for his senior, padded his stats and solidified a better draft projection? Or, was it because of the devaluation of RBs?
The league really has more RBs than it needs this day and age. Teams can throw just about anyone behind the QB and be alright.
The list of RBs on the past 10-15 or so SB winning squads is pretty ho-hum. Good players, sure, but you sure as shit can't name them off the top of your head.
I haven't seen many predictions, but my prediction is he will probably end up being a 4th or 5th round pick.
certain teams have certain needs, so it is always more important about which team actually selects you . . . Had Tim Couch gone to any other team . . . who knows . . . just me, but if I were an NFL GM, I would draft Benny first chance I got . . .
Last edited:
Yeah, it’s a tough position to stand out.
I wouldn’t ever doubt Benny though. He’s got the attitude, the work ethic, and the drive to make it.
I see him being at best case a late 3rd round pick, to a worst case middle 5th round pick.
Speed kills. It also kills your draft stock if you lack it.
Yep, and it’s kinda sad because he has football speed and not track speed. He ha incredible vision and that can’t be taught. That’s where a team will have to just watch tape and somewhat ignore his combine speed. He could go late in 5-6th and still be a good back for a team.
No way higher than a third imo. Alot depends on his combine which I expect to be disappointing. He succeeds in spite of his physical ability. Not because of it
I agree with you Grumpy.. I think unless he does get a 4.6 or better, he will fall to far and will need to work on it another year. It can be done with a lot of hard work and Benny has a lot of fire inside himself. I myself just don’t think he’s ready for the NFL and to be a Professional!! With all due respect to him, I Would certainly cheer for him if he goes, but he needs to become more mature and work on a few things. If he can work on that speed and gain just a little bit would do wonders an he can get in the 2-3 round. Just my opinion of course. I wish him the best no matter what he decides.
I’m going to say 4th round or later. His speed is going to hurt his draft stock. While he is a very good college running back the NFL is all about speed. Most dlinemen in the NFL are as fast as Benny.
I don't know what round but a guess would be 4th or 5th. BUT I think that Benny's thinking is, "you draft me and I'll show you".
Determination is just about as important as skill.
Determination is just about as important as skill.
He has and may still have a fantastic college career depending on what his decision is, But right or wrong the NFL places a premium on his biggest weakness. If he intends to leave, as soon as the bowl game is over the thing for him to do is hire a speed coach, work on his starts, his running technique and flexibility. For whatever reason BS26 has some bad running form. Work on those starts, improve his technique and he can pull a couple 10ths off his 40 time, which could mean the difference between a 2nd round pick and a 6th or 7th round pick. NFL defenses are just too fast for backs to not have decent speed or be very elusive, neither of those are Benny's deal.
My guess is that Benny runs in the 4.6s.....which can get you the 2nd rd. So, to me the speed isn’t as much an issue as not being versatile in the passing game. In the NFL you have to be a fairly well rounded back. Rose has 20-25% of the rushing carries that Snell has, but has 50% of the catches Snell has. If Snell can show the ability to catch, he can go in the 2nd....but I’m guessing 3-4th.
I agree with you 100%, and it really is a shame because he is very talented. I would love to see him become a better blocker also. That could actually make a team give a second look, despite his speed. Still, like you said, working with someone on his technique, would do wonders for his draft stock!! If he can get in the door, with his work ethic, he could end up being a very good one. One more thing, lol. Man, Nick Chubb looks unreal right now. You talk about being with the right place at the right time. I think they hit the jackpot with that young man. Sony also, looks very good. It’s amazing, that with losing two guys like that, without a few injuries, you wouldn’t have been able to tell they were gone. Haha. I really do appreciate the job Kirby is doing there, and he was born for that job. They are fun to watch. I think we’re going to be giving them a good challenge, the next couple of years. Thanks
It has taken Nick almost 3 years to come back from that knee injury his soph year. He came back his jr. year and wasn't anywhere near the sa Dra me back, quickness was gone. His sr year was better probably about 90%. But now, what could have been. Nick didn't tear his ACL, he tore the other 3, and no one works harder than he does, was just a devastating injury. .
Kirby surrounded himself with some good assistants and he isn't afraid to send them packing if they don't meet his work ethic. Rocker had a great reputation, but was lazy and got himself canned after 1 year.
It goes a long way of course, but they pay for numbers, and are quick to put a guy on the road for a ‘ bad game ‘ or two. It’s a crazy business. If it was just about heart though, Benny would be top ten in the NCAA. Selfishly, I do want him to come back. It will be a long time until we see another Benny Snell.
Yes, I hated to see him get hurt because I knew he was going to be special. A 90% Nick Chubb was one of the best I’ve saw. Lol. He’s one of my favorite players right now in the League. Such a great guy too. I remember they did that piece on his family, and I felt like one of them. Some of the best people in the world if you ask me. I sure hope he stays healthy, he deserves to get everything he can, and I’m looking forward to seeing, how great he can really be. Anyway, I’ve got the hit another day, and make it wish I stayed in the bed. Hahahaha Thanks and it was good to talk to you.
Sony and him are both great kids, were best friends in Athens. Never showed any jealously towards each other and we couldn't have asked for 2 better representatives of the school. The way they were used has really helped our RB recruiting too, Holyfield and Swift basically splitting carries keeps the wear and tear down on both. Holyfield could leave this year, but haven't heard anything yet one way or the other. U too, have a good one.
One other note on the NFL drafting running backs is there ability to play special teams. If you are a third back in the NFL, they really want you to be able to play special teams. We haven't seen Benny in the return game or his ability to make tackles on a punt or kickoff team, but that is a valuable asset to a NFL team as well.
Would love to hear how a fan of an NFL team would know in Nov who his team is “eyeing” as a 3rd round draft in June.
Best news for him is that teams now use more than one back to carry the load. While that devalues top end backs, it helps mid round backs like Benny because he's a good change of pace and potential specialist.
Add in that he's an excellent blocker and impressive catching the ball in limited opportunity, and hopefully it will make up for the lack of speed
Add in that he's an excellent blocker and impressive catching the ball in limited opportunity, and hopefully it will make up for the lack of speed
Similar threads
Latest posts
-
-
-
Transfer Portal BIG BOARD - Player Ratings Thread- Latest: Eight_Banners
-
