I'm not comparing the actions of Petrino to Tubby or Cal. But if you can't see that cal had major baggage when Uk hired him then we're living in different worlds. Being the head coach at two different programs stripped of entire seasons and final fours is not a good look. Being from Memphis I can also tell you Cal had major, and I mean major discipline issues at UM. Everything from arrest for inciting riots to soliciting prostitution. The Bell witch and Mitch spent a long time shifting through it all before the hire. Cal had baggage, and a good bit of it. what I'm arguing is the way UK fans were totally against Cal in the beginning. The difference is we knew we could land Cal, with some of these football coaches, since we can't really get them to begin with (or believe we can't) all of a sudden baggage is a no go. It's contradictory. Again, not comparing the MEN, comparing the situations and reactions of fans.
Look at at it this way. If a football coach who was recruiting to an extremely high level, the best in college football, was at a mid major program, and he had players in trouble for hookers, drugs, inciting riots in night clubs at 2am, two full football seasons stripped, and final appearances stripped, would you be ok with hiring him in football? This needs to be answered because that was Cals wrap sheet at UM. Don't like it but it was happening on his watch. Does it compare incident for incident at a school like UL? Hell no, but it's still a good bit of baggage.
Cal had to do what he had to do at Memphis. He played in the gray areas, there's no doubt about it. I live in Memphis and was very familiar with Cal prior to UK. I knew all the talking points before his arrival because Memphis fans said the exact same thing. I agree with it too. But he's no saint, and UK has afforded him the ability to leave the baggage behind and move on. He's done a tremendous job reviving his image. He's proven himself.
I'm friends with several college scouts and personnel. I work with them from time to time. College athletics is extremely dirty. most of the time fans have no idea how dirty it actually is. Kentucky has got to stop this BS of moral checks before we make hires. We did it with Cal the first time, Mitch tried to do it the second time, and we finally accepted it for what it is. And in basketball a little baggage hasn't hurt us one bit. Is Petrino capable of that, being he had far more damaging baggage? I'm not sure. No one knows. We will have the answer in the next decade. But If a man like Tressel is too dangerous to gamble on in football, we're done. Might as well stop watching. The best coaches have baggage, period. To hell with Petrino. I couldn't give two shits at this point. But we better take the moral blinders off if we ever want to succeed. We will need to take a few risks.
**edit - damnit, making me feel like I'm bashing Cal, which I'm not. But you're really underplaying some of the baggage.