From TankedCat
"I believe Pope will be in the mix with talent but we have to move away from thinking that landing a 5 star kid is more meaningful than landing a 4 star veteran guy that took his team on a deep NCAA tourney run.
It's about "buying" the pieces to a team in the transfer portal, not recruiting athletes that have zero experience competing at the next level."
Agree completely!
The elite freshmen are most likely going to do the following:
1. Go to NBA draft after 1 year - for the $$$, NIL cannot compete
2. Transfer - I did not have a draft type year - Must be the coach!
Coach Pope has done a marvelous job with a new staff and players that never played together before this season. Plus, the injuries in the toughest (top to Bottom) SEC that I have seen in my nearly 60 years of being a UK fan. Yes, we lost some games that maybe we should have won but also won some games against more talented teams that had returning players and coaches.
As far as putting together a roster, I believe you need a balance of returning players, recruits from the portal, and high school. What is the mixture? With the ridiculous NIL and transfer portal that is presently in place, every team in the nation is going to have upheaval in the roster every year.
- The returning players have to judge both playing time and $$$ when deciding to stay or leave.
- The transfer portal had over 2,000 players in it this past offseason. A coach and his staff have to somehow sift through this list and determine the character, fit, and yes the money. You cannot get multiple 5* and the top portal players.
- Most, if not all, of the 5* freshmen think they are going to the NBA. So their focus is usually on the $$$ and the coach they feel will propel their status and not so much on winning a championship in their 1 year in college.
I think Rick Pitino is correct in focusing on the Portal players to build his team at St Johns. Every player (high school to graduate player) has to be considered a "1-year rental." As Tanked stated, do you want a 5* kid that has proven he can play on the scholastic level or a less talented player who has proven he is a good player on the collegiate level? I prefer recruiting proven college "basketball players" over high school athletes with great measurables.
I am hoping that Coach Pope will get 4-5 guys from the portal who have more that 1 year of eligibility at UK. This year he was hamstrung by the lack of time he had to evaluate portal guys and did an admirable job getting the guys presently on our team. Maybe not the most talented, but a few years down the road we may see them as the catalyst for bringing UK back.