Well, first off, in defense of my opinion that Bogans is one of UK's best all around players, let's review his career stats. The number in () is his rank among guards
Points 1923 #4 (#1)
Rebounds 552 #39 (#3)
Assists 314 #17 (#16)
Steals 155 #12 (#8)
Lets compare Bogans to the other guards among the top 20 all time scorers. Stats are per game Player/Bogans (difference)
Tony Delk - #5 all time scoring
ppg 14.21/14.24 (-0.03)
rpg 3.53/4.09 (-0.56)
apg 1.58/2.33 (-0.75)
spg 1.51/1.15 (+0.36)
Ed Davender - #11 all time scoring
ppg 12.69/14.24 (-1.55)
rpg 2.34/4.09 (-1.75)
apg 3.38/2.33 (+1.05)
spg1.48/1.15 (+0.33)
Louie Dampier - #12 all time scoring
ppg 19.69/14.24 (+5.45)
rpg 5.11/4.09 (+1.02)
apg 1.68/2.33 (-0.65)
Ralph Beard - #15 all time scoring
ppg 10.91/14.24 (-4.33)
Joe Crawford - #20 all time scoring
ppg 11.32/14.24 (-2.92)
rpg 3.35/4.09 (-0.74)
apg 1.50/2.33 (-0.83)
spg 0.48/1.15 (-0.67)
There's a lot of red up there.
Now let's lay to rest the Bogans vs Wade debate. No doubt Bogans was somewhat handicapped by a bum ankle, but the Bogans/Wade duel wasn't what determined the game. Wade scored 8.5 points more than his average vs Marquette's other four NCAA opponents, true, but the real reason UK lost that game was the Robert Jackson/Marquis Estill battle. Jackson outscored Estill 24-10. Jackson scored 13.25 points more than his average against the rest of their NCAA opponents. Wade had the most points, but it's really Jackson who was the decisive player that game. And it didn't help that Chuck Hayes, who was averaging 8.61 ppg was held scoreless.