Legacy? well, since you used that word...
Sparky Anderson lost 104 games in 1989 and was well under .500 the last seven years he managed...He's in the Hall of Fame for the Big Red Machine and then taking Detroit to the 1984 Championship. That's his legacy. No one outside of a few bitter nuts look back at the late 1980s and say, "Sparky? He wasn't so great."
How about Adolph Rupp? His last championship was 15 years before he retired.
No one remembers Babe Ruth for his bloated final years with the Boston Braves. No one remembers the dreck Hemingway wrote after "Old Man in the Sea" or the paper cutouts Matisse messed around with in his last years, or really any of the last 15 or so albums by Miles Davis or anything the Rolling Stones did after Exile on Main Street in 1972 , and on and on.
A legacy is established by what you do at the height of your powers that separates you from the commonplace and that helps define an era; a place and time.
If Calipari doesn't turn things around at Kentucky next year, his legacy will be building Massachusetts from nothing to a Final Four program, taking Memphis to the Final Game, and coming to Kentucky when the program was in shambles and between 2010 and 2019 winning a championship, going to four Final Fours and seven Elite Eights. He'll be remembered as the guy who first recognized the potential in the NBA's new rule making kids wait until they turned 19 to be drafted, and turning that into a great run at Kentucky. Sure, like with Dean Smith and others there will be the shadow over that -- he should have won more championships. But his legacy is secure.
Sorry to disappoint those filled with anger and hatred right now because of the disappointments of the past few years, but his legacy is about as solid as it gets.
I won’t just assume Cal Cultist or anything like that as others have done, but would wonder if you are capable of conversation on the topic.
Legacy can have several meanings but one I saw stated “ the long-lasting impact of particular events, actions, etc. that took place in the past, or of a person’s life.”
Elvis, Babe Ruth, sparky Anderson, Adolph Rupp built things that have stood since they created them or are still talked about, revered and loved to this day. Using them as an example in defending Cal is just odd.
What long lasting impact has John Calipari had on any program that is even close to comparable of those 4? Umass…. Went to nothing when he left, Memphis… has not shown they will ever be close to what Cal had. Not to mention that technically he didn’t even take those programs to the final four as you stated. He left both programs in scandals and he will more than likely leave UK in shambles when he leaves.
Cal’s legacy will be NBA draft picks and that’s what he has always wanted it to be. I don’t think it’s even debatable that is what he will be remembered for.
Legacy is not what you were at the top of your game or at the lowest point of a legendary career, it is what you are remembered as, what is that lasting impact.
You want to give examples here are a few others:
Pete rose: all time hit king, what is he remembered for? Betting on baseball
Barry Bonds: all time home run leader, arguably the best baseball player ever, what is he known for? Steroids
Rick pitino: title at UK, great overall career what is he known for? 15 seconds and hookers for his players
If a miracle occurs and Cal gets a second title at Kentucky he will be revered for the rest of time and fans will come back and love him and be happy and the last few years will be looked passed, but in the end the NBA drafts will be what he is known for.