I guess we shall see mcnic. We'll see. Are you hoping he falls on his face so you can be right? That would be a sad state of affairs, but I think you're pretty close to being there.
Here's my last word on the topic. If he is playing terrible, I don't want him on the floor. Period. But if he is playing like he did before the injury, he can contribute. A healthy Mitchell could especially help against a zone defense. That's all I want. I hope that when he gets in, he does well. Don't you?
Edit: by the way, there is no "infatuation" here. Re-read my comments. IF he's playing well, he could help. That's the entire point of the thread. If he's not, take him out. Does that sound like infatuation to you? And by the way, aren't we cheering for the same team? You argue with this anger and aggression that I just don't understand.
Here is what this boils down to...and it's a good debate to be honest.
1. If you want to play Mitchell...he has to play PF or C. So whose minutes do you want to reduce?
2. If it's at Center
- I want Ivisic to get 20 minutes at least...I feel Mitchell directly eats into Ivisic's minutes.
- Cal has his defense boner concept that will never go away...and since Ugo is the strongest defender...he's going to get some run
- Bradshaw has almost lost all minutes...but seems like Cal gives him 4 minutes regardless
3. If Mitchell plays PF
- We get much slower if he's paired with Ugo/Ivisic as the Center when he plays
- I think Thiero is a better shot blocker, better on ball defender (on switches) and a bit less rebounder...but not by much IMO. On offensive end, Thiero is a far superior ball handler, drives it better, stronger finisher. Most imagine Tre is a better shooter but Thiero is shooting 31.8% from 3pt land and Tre 31.3% from 3pt land. So it's a wash...Tre has been ice cold before his shoulder injury and even colder since.
- Edwards is a better shooter, ball handler....but less rebounder and strong post presence. But Edwards is quicker and better on ball screens defense
To me this boils down to....Tre is our best post offense but his deep shooting has been non existent for a while. Tre doesn't really add any defense which is what this team needs more than any offense.
I just think we found a killer lineup with:
PG - Reed
SG - Dilly
SG/SF - Reeves
PF - Thiero (or Edwards)
C - Ivisic
This lineup is amazing offensively and not a huge drop-off defensively/rebounding from guys like DJ, Ugo, Mitchell, Bradshaw, etc.. playing in different combinations. I just feel like Cal doesn't need a reason to play slower lineups which is what Mitchell gives him a reason to do.