ADVERTISEMENT

UK Draft Round 1 - JHannibalSmith vs. Fox2monk

Who would win in a 1 game elimination?


  • Total voters
    26
  • Poll closed .

DraftCat

Senior
Nov 5, 2011
6,294
9,366
113
Welcome to March Madness this is Round 1 of the 2024 UK Draft. (Click Here for Bracket).

Voters - Please vote for the team you believe would win in a 1 game elimination format. You will be able to change your vote and voting period is open for 48 hours. If a tie should occur I will extend the voting by another 2 hours until the tie is broken. Your vote will be visible.


@JHannibalSmith - Ron Mercer, Kyle Macy, Rex Chapman, Melvin Turpin, Walter McCarty, Kelenna Azubuike, Kevin Knox, Dirk Minniefield, Jim Andrews, Mike Casey, Dominique Hawkins

vs.

@Fox2monk - Tayshaun Prince, De'Aaron Fox, Bam Adebayo, Chuck Hayes, Travis Ford, Cotton Nash, Joe Crawford, Pat Riley, Derrick Miller, Randolph Morris, Junior Braddy
 
giphy.gif
 
Lineup

PG Kyle Macy 6-3
SG Rex Chapman 6-4
SF Ron Mercer 6-7
PF Walter McCarty 6-10
C Melvin Turpin 6-11

PG Dirk Minniefield 6-3
SG Mike Casey 6-4
G/F Kelenna Azubuike 6-5
SF Kevin Knox 6-9
F/C Jim Andrews 6-11
CG Dominique Hawkins 6-0

Depth Chart

PG: Kyle Macy, Dirk Minniefield, Rex Chapman, Dom Hawkins
SG: Rex Chapman, Mike Casey, Kelenna Azubuike, Dominique Hawkins
SF: Ron Mercer, Kelenna Azubuike or Kevin Knox, Rex Chapman, Mike Casey
PF: Walter McCarty, Jim Andrews, Kevin Knox, Ron Mercer
C: Melvin Turpin, Jim Andrews, Walter McCarty

Personally, I think these guys would fit very well, together. I can’t vouch for Casey’s defense, but, everyone else is, at worst, a solid defender. Even Knox when he wanted to. Macy was a good defensive player, too. But, I also have Dirk to throw at the more athletic PGs. He was a freak, too, & could be a problem, defensively. And, he was 3X ALL-SEC, himself. And, he was SECT MVP in 82 & is still the all-time assist leader at UK.

They’re all skilled, offensively. Several can play multiple positions, so, the lineup possibilities are limitless. Macy was the ultimate college PG, though, IMO. Basically, a coach on the floor. Elite shooter & play maker & clutch af. Automatic at the FT line. Late lead & it’s over. He & Rex would be deadly on the perimeter.

Rex, IMO, is as good & as skilled as any SG that I’ve seen at UK. Literally, nothing he couldn’t do. Great shooter & really athletic. 3 level scorer. He might be the best passing 2 I’ve seen, as well. Incredible court vision & awareness. He & Mercer would be electric on the wings.

Mercer was another super skilled player. 3 level scorer & high flyer. He was a good defender, IMO, too. But, defenses would have to pick their poison & there should be plenty of open looks for everybody. He had the ability to completely take over games. Just a dominant player.

McCarty is the ideal complement at the 4 & small ball 5. Long & athletic & skilled on both ends. He’s a nice secondary rim protector & can be a lockdown defender & matchup nightmare. And, he shot 47% from 3 his SR season, on 2 attempts/game.

Turpin was another guy who excelled on both ends. He was a solid shooter out to 15-16 ft & had a bag of post moves & fakes. Had a career high of 42 against UT. He was an elite shot blocker, averaging 3 per game his JR season.

Casey & Andrews are both good enough to be starters on a team, IMO. Casey was another shooter who could score in a myriad of ways. Nice turnaround J & good taking the ball to the basket. Very good passer & rebounder. Averaged 7 rebounds/game for his career. Ppl have called him a shorter Larry Bird bc of his skillset. He was 3X ALL-SEC.

Andrews also had a good midrange game for a big & shot 56% & 58% from the field in the 2 seasons he played serious minutes. He averaged over 20/10 in each of those seasons & was 1st Team All-SEC both years. He had 43 double-doubles in his UK career. He would be the primary backup at both the 4 & 5. Ideally, McCarty, Turpin & Andrews get around 25 mpg each at the 4 & 5.

Azubuike & Knox also provide instant offense & versatility off the bench. Knox would be used for specific units & matchups, mostly. But, IMO, he could be a matchup problem as a small ball 4 or as a SG in a huge lineup. Both are athletic guys who are above average perimeter shooters & great finishers at the rim.

All these guys have shown up for the big games, too. 3 have won National Championships. Everyone, even the walk-on Hawkins, made at least one All-SECT team. Macy, Rex, Mercer & Minniefield were all SECT MVPs. Macy & Mercer were SEC POY.

It’s a team that can beat you several different ways, on both ends of the court, IMO. Great depth & versatility. Collectively, a fundamentally sound & high IQ team that won’t beat itself. There is also plenty of size, length & athleticism. But, IMO, I think the fit is my best argument. I, honestly, think this group would work perfectly, together. And, most are already accustomed to sharing the minutes with a loaded roster & sacrificing numbers for Ws.
 
Last edited:
Marking this post to vote later. But, I do have a question....poll ends today at 7:58 or in 48 hrs...tomorrow at 7:58?
 
Who's winning? I don't want to cast a vote. I can't make a final choice.
It’s tied. Guard play wins championships in March (April). And, IMO, my 3 headed back court monster is as good as anybody’s. Macy is as elite as it gets for a college PG. He was the heart & soul of his teams, on both ends. A true leader & floor general who was an extension of the coach on the floor.

He was cool under pressure & thrived in the clutch, too. And, he’s one of the 5 best shooters I’ve, personally, seen at UK. Textbook form & stroke. And, he could score off the bounce & at the rim, as well. Extremely crafty. With Rex & Mercer on the wings, Macy would have no shortage of open looks. And, defenses have to respect him out to 20 feet, creating more than enough space for the wings to work.

Mercer & Rex are perfect complements. Both are athletic, top shelf, 3 level scorers who were pretty damn good in big games, too. Rex was also an elite shooter. And, Mercer was above average from 3, but, he was money if he got an open look. But, both guys had no problem scoring on contested shots & finishing at the rim in traffic. Check out these Rex highlights & tell me that this back court is anything less than unstoppable.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Son_Of_Saul
It’s tied. Guard play wins championships in March (April). And, IMO, my 3 headed back court monster is as good as anybody’s. Macy is as elite as it gets for a college PG. He was the heart & soul of his teams, on both ends. A true leader & floor general who was an extension of the coach on the floor.

He was cool under pressure & thrived in the clutch, too. And, he’s one of the 5 best shooters I’ve, personally, seen at UK. Textbook form & stroke. And, he could score off the bounce & at the rim, as well. Extremely crafty. With Rex & Mercer on the wings, Macy would have no shortage of open looks. And, defenses have to respect him out to 20 feet, creating more than enough space for the wings to work.

Mercer & Rex are perfect complements. Both are athletic, top shelf, 3 level scorers who were pretty damn good in big games, too. Rex was also an elite shooter. And, Mercer was above average from 3, but, he was money if he got an open look. But, both guys had no problem scoring on contested shots & finishing at the rim in traffic. Check out these Rex highlights & tell me that this back court is anything less than unstoppable.

Good post. I can't bring myself to vote until I get eliminated. It's just too convoluted in terms of potential bias.

You've constructed a hell of a team, though. I think both of your rosters would give my guys fits.
 
  • Like
Reactions: drcats2013
Good post. I can't bring myself to vote until I get eliminated. It's just too convoluted in terms of potential bias.

You've constructed a hell of a team, though. I think both of your rosters would give my guys fits.
The first part of this I respect a ton. I fear voting hurts me for whoever I vote against, but I try to do it as we don’t get a ton of traffic on these as is.
 
I think my argument would be that my team is a defensive monster. Fox is one of the best PG’s in the world and of all time here. He’s a good perimeter defender too. Prince, Hayes, and Bam need no defensive hype as they were some of the best in college and the NBA.

I think I have enough shooting with Miller, Riley was an AA and 3x All SEC player, Travis Ford was a sniper, and Cotton Nash has some of the best career stats in UK history. Randolph Morris is a super high quality back up big man. All SEC his Junior year. Oh yeah Joe Crawford was an amazing SG and one of the only reasons the last year of Tubby and first of BCG were anything decent at all. Heck of a back up guard. Also, who has a better coach on the floor than Pat Riley?
 
Last edited:
The first part of this I respect a ton. I fear voting hurts me for whoever I vote against, but I try to do it as we don’t get a ton of traffic on these as is.
The voting is the only thing I don’t like about these drafts. In most cases, I’ve noticed that ppl here are either seriously uneducated on the past or they have zero respect for it. So, don’t get your hopes up if you aren’t loaded down with recent players. I just enjoy drafting & couldn’t care less about the results bc the voting is rarely realistic. I learned that in my first draft.
 
The voting is the only thing I don’t like about these drafts. In most cases, I’ve noticed that ppl here are either seriously uneducated on the past or they have zero respect for it. So, don’t get your hopes up if you aren’t loaded down with recent players. I just enjoy drafting & couldn’t care less about the results bc the voting is rarely realistic. I learned that in my first draft.

I've thought about just doing a huge poll with everyone listed and see who the majority thinks all in 1 shot.

But feels a little anti-climatic even if it's more work for me lol
 
The voting is the only thing I don’t like about these drafts. In most cases, I’ve noticed that ppl here are either seriously uneducated on the past or they have zero respect for it. So, don’t get your hopes up if you aren’t loaded down with recent players. I just enjoy drafting & couldn’t care less about the results bc the voting is rarely realistic. I learned that in my first draft.
I really enjoyed watching you all draft. I'm not looking forward to voting although I think I have it narrowed down to my 3 favorites, but it sure was difficult. I wish someone would have drafted all my picks for best players so it would have been easier.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT