ADVERTISEMENT

"Perspective on jayden Qaintances recovery time frame from acl injury"

When you are young and with all the science currently out on injury this used to be career ending (especially in football)... Now the average time back is 8-10 months from what I have read.
Derek Anderson tore his ACL in January 1997 & I believe the doctors told the UK coaches that Anderson was good to get back in game action in March. Pitino was afraid to take a chance with Anderson reinjuring it so he refused to play him. Pitino did put him in the Final Four game against Minnesota to shoot 2 technical free throws which he made...... So there's a good chance that Quaintance gets back earlier than some might think.
 
That KSR article is a good and balanced article.

All we can do is hope the kid heals as he should, and on time.
Good thing is we have a ton of front court depth now so he can take his time. I would rather have him close to 100% in January for the Conference run into March rather than rush him back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SemperFiCat
My questions is If he tore it in February, why did it take over a month to have surgery on it?
My son had surgery about 3 weeks after his injury. Part of that delay was not knowing the extent of the injury due to waiting to get an MRI done. Also, the local orthopedic doctor refused to do surgery because of the extent of the damage so he referred him to the top orthopedic surgeon that routinely does repairs on athletes to give my son a chance to play again. Sometimes you just have to wait for the best surgeon to be able to get to you. That could be the case with JQ, because I hope he got the best surgeon possible. Who does your surgery makes a HUGE difference in your recovery and if you're ever going to play ball again.
 
March 19th surgery date.
I wouldn't put him fully ready to go until SEC play.
That doesn't mean he can't "play", but I think people need to pump the brakes thinking he's going to be the starting center in November.

I think there's a legit reason Brandon Garrison returned. There is ample playing time at the 5, especially early in the year, where he is likely the starting center for a few months.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SemperFiCat
Derek Anderson tore his ACL in January 1997 & I believe the doctors told the UK coaches that Anderson was good to get back in game action in March. Pitino was afraid to take a chance with Anderson reinjuring it so he refused to play him. Pitino did put him in the Final Four game against Minnesota to shoot 2 technical free throws which he made...... So there's a good chance that Quaintance gets back earlier than some might think.
Anderson's injury happend at a time that they were experimenting with accelerated rehab protocols, which was abandoned pretty quickly. He also had a cadaver graft which was a component in his time frame. Those are still done but not usually with elite athletes. The timeframes are subject to human physiology and rushing things usually isnt a great attitude to have
 
You often have to wait for swelling to go down before you can schedule it and I’m sure they saw a couple different doctors first to get multiple opinions as well.
And this comment in the article “Some athletes have returned to sport in as little as six months, but those were simple tears. No one has confirmed Jayden Quaintance’s tear to be of the simple variety, and any whispers claiming this to be the case are more than likely the result of wishful thinking.”

I don’t think any thinking is wishful on this. If he says he will be back in September that is either wishful thinking on JQs part that’s why I believe it to be a partial tear. No way would he be so optimistic on timeline. It’s not speculation it’s just going with what Jayden’s dad has stated.
 
To me that says probably Jan. With hope for Dec.
Other than no one knows the degree. I feel like every month extra he gets the healthier he will be for a run. I wouldn’t sit too long but the cupcake game around the UL time will be a good time to get him on the court for a conference run
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: chroix
Good thing he’s young as hell. Hoping for a quick recovery and from what we’ve heard him say himself sounds like he’s on track.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ron Mehico
The biggest issue is time for the graft to grow/heal together. In the meantime, light mobility therapy, progressing to light exercising and weight bearing, then strength building exercises. In my case, the most recent knee surgery, was complete acl replacement with a cadaver ligament. Once the graft is secure, by growing back together, most of the rest becomes physical rehab and building back muscle that it what supports our joints. Biggest concern is during the time for the bone to grow back together and securing the new ligament. There are things that can be done to speed that process a bit regarding blood flow etc that promote bone healing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: catfan220
Good thing is we have a ton of front court depth now so he can take his time. I would rather have him close to 100% in January for the Conference run into March rather than rush him back.
That's probably what Pope sold Garrison on to keep him here. He's going to be a vital piece, Especially early if JQ isn't ready.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeffky and chroix
And this comment in the article “Some athletes have returned to sport in as little as six months, but those were simple tears. No one has confirmed Jayden Quaintance’s tear to be of the simple variety, and any whispers claiming this to be the case are more than likely the result of wishful thinking.”

I don’t think any thinking is wishful on this. If he says he will be back in September that is either wishful thinking on JQs part that’s why I believe it to be a partial tear. No way would he be so optimistic on timeline. It’s not speculation it’s just going with what Jayden’s dad has stated.
I couldve sworn I read JQ’s dad said it was a partial tear. If you watch the actual injury it didnt look nearly as bad as some do. He stayed on the bench the rest of the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeffky
The biggest issue is time for the graft to grow/heal together. In the meantime, light mobility therapy, progressing to light exercising and weight bearing, then strength building exercises. In my case, the most recent knee surgery, was complete acl replacement with a cadaver ligament. Once the graft is secure, by growing back together, most of the rest becomes physical rehab and building back muscle that it what supports our joints. Biggest concern is during the time for the bone to grow back together and securing the new ligament. There are things that can be done to speed that process a bit regarding blood flow etc that promote bone healing.
What I hate to see is kids who recover from these surgeries out playing with no kind of brace or support, especially early after that kind of injury. Hopefully if he does come back early like we hope, he at least wears something to give it some stability.
 
Other than no one knows the degree. I feel like every month extra he gets the healthier he will be for a run. I wouldn’t sit too long but the cupcake game around the UL time will be a good time to get him on the court for a conference run
I'm not a doctor. But I can play one on the innerweb.
 
I'm not a doctor. But I can play one on the innerweb.
Im just going off the projected time frame evidently his dr gave him for contact. Ideally based on that being conservative expect 3 months more since these recoveries can be unpredictable
 
I have had ACL/Meniscal surgery both recently and as a high school senior (three decades ago sheesh). I can tell you that it was easier as an older man to get back to life and the surgery was far less invasive than when I was 18 years old. I am in no way in any type of shape to play a sport of any kind, just want to point out that he is young and an incredibly gifted athlete - this is not a death sentence for the kids playing career nor the kids season. If anything he will likely be more explosive as a result of all of the PT he is going to have to do to get his knee back to where it needs to be!
 
  • Like
Reactions: kywildcat41035
And this comment in the article “Some athletes have returned to sport in as little as six months, but those were simple tears. No one has confirmed Jayden Quaintance’s tear to be of the simple variety, and any whispers claiming this to be the case are more than likely the result of wishful thinking.”

I don’t think any thinking is wishful on this. If he says he will be back in September that is either wishful thinking on JQs part that’s why I believe it to be a partial tear. No way would he be so optimistic on timeline. It’s not speculation it’s just going with what Jayden’s dad has stated.
If he had ACL reconstruction it wouldnt matter if it was partial or complete tear as they resect the whole thing and use a graft. I will say that an athletic activity that has enough velocity to tear an acl almost always results in a complete tear from my experience. Again 6 months would be really optimistic and not optimal for long term joint health and stability
 
The biggest issue is time for the graft to grow/heal together. In the meantime, light mobility therapy, progressing to light exercising and weight bearing, then strength building exercises. In my case, the most recent knee surgery, was complete acl replacement with a cadaver ligament. Once the graft is secure, by growing back together, most of the rest becomes physical rehab and building back muscle that it what supports our joints. Biggest concern is during the time for the bone to grow back together and securing the new ligament. There are things that can be done to speed that process a bit regarding blood flow etc that promote bone healing.
My son had a complete ACL replacement except they used part of his patella ligament, which required a little strengthening rehab before the surgery to help with his remaining patella ligament. Since he had to sit out basketball too he has lifted weights like crazy this winter and has gotten as strong as a bull.
 
What I hate to see is kids who recover from these surgeries out playing with no kind of brace or support, especially early after that kind of injury. Hopefully if he does come back early like we hope, he at least wears something to give it some stability.
The doctors made a couple if braces specifically for my son. The first one was really big and restrictive. It had locking hinges to help with support. As he progressed the next brace was made for him to use while playing. He's supposed to only wear it through the summer for 7 on 7 scrimmages in football and for summer basketball but he plans to keep wearing it at least through next football season.
 
Good thing is we have a ton of front court depth now so he can take his time. I would rather have him close to 100% in January for the Conference run into March rather than rush him back.
I am having a hard time looking at that avatar fox I liked the other one better
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fox2monk
What I hate to see is kids who recover from these surgeries out playing with no kind of brace or support, especially early after that kind of injury. Hopefully if he does come back early like we hope, he at least wears something to give it some stability.
Nothing really wrong with a brace but muscle is your brace, once built back. It's how we were built and an athlete, even more so. In my case, it was a cadaver patella tendon used to replace my acl. Based on my own recovery experience from both partial and complete tears, I wouldn't even consider anything other than complete acl replacement...but I'm not a dr. But, my doc did tell me my options and that the cadver patella replacement was significantly stronger, once fully healed, than my acl ever was. He stated percentages but I don't recall for sure...seems like 160% stronger than OE. I asked if I'd be able to jump higher afterward but we won't go any further than that...Lol! But seriously, assuming the graft and replacement fully heals, the new acl "should" be able to take more strain, being stronger than oe. I can see a value there with a true athlete. Therapy is by far the most important aspect but things like blood circulation to the repair are factors in how soon it will heal. Bottom line, I've been through three pretty serious knee surgeries over a wide span of time that saw vast changes and improvement in acl surgeries. It is vastly better that it was in the 90's, when orthoscopic was in its infancy stage. I'm not as worried as a lot on here seem to be.

It takes time for the bone to heal. During that time. ya lose strength that supports the joint. And it takes time to build that strength back. That's why most sports drs have you moving the next day and starting light therapy, without delay.
 
Had a 17 year old tore acl last football game of season. Anchored a 4 x 400 relay team that spring camee in second in state. 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeffky
Nothing really wrong with a brace but muscle is your brace, once built back. It's how we were built and an athlete, even more so. In my case, it was a cadaver patella tendon used to replace my acl. Based on my own recovery experience from both partial and complete tears, I wouldn't even consider anything other than complete acl replacement...but I'm not a dr. But, my doc did tell me my options and that the cadver patella replacement was significantly stronger, once fully healed, than my acl ever was. He stated percentages but I don't recall for sure...seems like 160% stronger than OE. I asked if I'd be able to jump higher afterward but we won't go any further than that...Lol! But seriously, assuming the graft and replacement fully heals, the new acl "should" be able to take more strain, being stronger than oe. I can see a value there with a true athlete. Therapy is by far the most important aspect but things like blood circulation to the repair are factors in how soon it will heal. Bottom line, I've been through three pretty serious knee surgeries over a wide span of time that saw vast changes and improvement in acl surgeries. It is vastly better that it was in the 90's, when orthoscopic was in its infancy stage. I'm not as worried as a lot on here seem to be.

It takes time for the bone to heal. During that time. ya lose strength that supports the joint. And it takes time to build that strength back. That's why most sports drs have you moving the next day and starting light therapy, without delay.
Yeah, my son did therapy the next day before we drove back home to Kentucky. He started therapy 3x/week immediately.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT