To be fair, ever seen 'beautiful' Hollywood celebs w/out makeup - some of them are REALLY not very attractive at all. So, yes, makeup, hairdo, etc. do make a difference. But the pictures accompanying the article aren't all glamour shots and she's a very attractive woman. Looks like she's kept the bod in shape, too.
Now, why a 43-year old is messing around with <16 year child is beyond my comprehension. Very possible she has children older than that. Once age is considered, I'd put her at about 7.5 on the hot/crazy scale. I'm guessing she could've set her sights on a 20-something with a Mrs. Robinson complex and would have been just as happy without, you know, going to jail.