ADVERTISEMENT

Bracket: Best Baseball Movie

HeismaNole

Senior
Nov 29, 2023
4,489
19,454
113
9q5579.jpg


Maybe @funKYcat75 can do what he did for the Christmas Movie Tourney and do a poll for each of these (assuming he's a baseball fan)?


Who you got?
 
No bracket needed. The Natural is the GOAT and Field of Dreams right there next.

Terrible bracket, fwiw.....no 42 or Bingo Long.
I had 42 but Mr. Baseball was ranked higher in the baseball movies list so I included that as the play-in.

Still 42 isn't anywhere close to the top 10 baseball movies which are all in here.

Talent for the Game is one I like but doesn't make it. Sugar was also on the table. Little Big League was the other kids baseball movie from the 90s.
 
I love the Sandlot but it’s not beating the original Bad News Bears.

The Natural is the best baseball movie ever imo- Major League is my favorite.

Most underrated- 61*

Costner’s best baseball movie is Bull Durham.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PhDcat2018
First Round:

East Bracket - West Bracket

Mr Baseball - Field of Dreams
Pride of the Yankees - A league of their own
The Rookie - Bad News Bears
Major League - For the Love of the Game

Second Round:

Pride of the Yankees - Field of Dreams
Major League - Bad News Bears

Third Round:

Major League - Bad News Bears

Winner

Major League
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TheFrontRunner
Field of Dreams for me. It was fun to see MLB play at the Field of Dreams twice and the Reds be apart of it in the 2nd game.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sefleming
9q5579.jpg


Maybe @funKYcat75 can do what he did for the Christmas Movie Tourney and do a poll for each of these (assuming he's a baseball fan)?


Who you got?
First round winners: Bull Durham, Eight Men Out, The Natural, Major League, Field of Dreams, A League of Their Own, Bad News Bears (the original one), Moneyball
Final 4: Eight Men Out, Major League, A League of Their Own, Bad News Bears
Finals: Major League, A League of Their Own
Champ: Major League
 
Bull Durham sucks and is really just a lame romantic comedy dressed up as a baseball movie to trick men into watching it.
Movies like Bad News Bears and 8 Men Out are far superior. Even The Sandlot, which I didn’t see until I was an adult is better.
Sorry it had to be said
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catman100
Seems many haven’t heard of Long Gone, the HBO movie back in 1987. It’s free here on YouTube.




I like it better than Bull Durham. In terms of baseball scenes in a movie, For Love of the Game is second to none. It’s just that there’s all of the romance with Kelly Preston stuff for the rest of movie which kills it.
 
Seems many haven’t heard of Long Gone, the HBO movie back in 1987. It’s free here on YouTube.




I like it better than Bull Durham. In terms of baseball scenes in a movie, For Love of the Game is second to none. It’s just that there’s all of the romance with Kelly Preston stuff for the rest of movie which kills it.
Long Gone is a great baseball flick. Absurd that it is a “play-in” team. Blow out win by 30+ in that game. Double digit win against Bull Durham in the next round. Only reason it wouldn’t get past the Elite Eight is because the selection committee screwed them. Eight Men out wins that one in OT.

Cantrell’s Rule: Eff ‘em if they can’t take a joke.
 
"Cobb" is one of my favorite baseball movies. It belongs in the tournament, IMO.
 
Long Gone is a great baseball flick. Absurd that it is a “play-in” team. Blow out win by 30+ in that game. Double digit win against Bull Durham in the next round. Only reason it wouldn’t get past the Elite Eight is because the selection committee screwed them. Eight Men out wins that one in OT.

Cantrell’s Rule: Eff ‘em if they can’t take a joke.
I only put it there cause besides my brother and I, no one else had heard of it when I talk about it until now. Glad to see a fellow fan!
 
Baseball movies are lightyears ahead of movies about other sports.
That's because baseball is the worst sport. Nothing happens. And it takes no talent. So you can have close ups of theater kids staring off in to the distance thinking about settling down on a farm for three minutes. Cut ahead two hours in to the game when the next action happens and audience isn't lost. Show things in slow motion and not annoy viewers who would rather see exciting alley oops in real time.
 
Last edited:
The original Bad News Bears for the upset....you can take your bracket and your trophy and shove 'em straight up your ass!

Probably Major League for me.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT