My comment about 2nd round was based on his draft projection. Never did I say that "he will be a 2nd rounder". Many mock drafts at the time of his declaring projected him as a 2nd rounder. Hindsight is 20/20 now that he went lottery. I'm thrilled for the kid but I stand by my opinion that if Cal wants to win titles he MUST find a way to get "fringe first round" kids to stay. It's imperative.
I stand by my opinion that Cal's penchant for getting kids to the pros as quickly as possible will make it very difficult to win "titles". It's great for the kids but basically counterproductive given the recipe required to win a title. In short, his greatest strength is also his greatest detrimate (as it pertains to winning titles). UK gets the best recruits (strength), because they are the best they leave early (detrimate) I don't really want to explain it again because it draws such vigor and vitriol from the masses and I understand. The Cats are the most important thing in the lives of many. It's only natural to defend something so beloved.
It's my opinion (and I'm entirely entitled to it), that a team made up of majority freshmen, with no "talented" upperclassmen CANNOT win the title. 2012's title doesn't debunk this opinion, it defends it. Darius Miller was as good an all-around player as anyone. He had serious game. You combined him with some very talented returning players in Jones and Lamb, and then combined them with arguably the greatest and most decorated freshmen of all time (AD), and another talented enough freshmen to go 2nd overall, and you get a national title.
The problem is that was Cal's 3rd year. He didn't convince Miller to stay, Miller just did. Had he recruited Miller to UK, would he have made it to his senior year as talented as he was?
Last year's team to me was actually the perfect recipe. You had very quality upperclassmen players in Willis and Hawkins to go along with oober talented freshmen and they almost won it had it not been for one very rogue official.
To put a bow on this, for a final time; my opinion is that you must have a combination of quality upper classmen players to go with these talented freshmen in order to win the title. It simply cannot be done with freshmen alone. I actually don't see what's so offensive about that. It's not some bold opinion, history tells us as much.
I don't think Cal has created an atmosphere where it's ok to "stay", therefore I think our chances of retaining a quality upperclassmen player will be slim. It's why I hated it when Marcus Lee transferred, Charles Matthews, Wiltjer, etc. I hated it when Briscoe and Humphries declared. We needed those guys. And I hate it when fans get down on a Wynard, or SKJ because they're not coming along as quickly as these other superstar freshmen. It's ok. Let them grow and develop and most importantly.....STAY.
You must have quality upperclassmen players to win a title. UK doesn't promote that type of atmosphere. What Cal is doing now will win a lot of games and get you close, but no, I don't think it wins the big one.
Just my opinion and I know it offends but I'm assuming I'm not entirely alone on that fear/opinion.