Which one wins out and why? For me, Duke is pushed down everyone's throat so much its easily the victor in this one. I respect their record, but enough is enough. UL - I just don't follow them that closely.
I really dislike Duke, but it is not even in the same solar system with UL. If they play, I am a Duke fan, for the day. Heck, I can say that about any other team, that plays UL. I have even gone and bought a cap of their opponent and worn it, during the NCAA tournament.
UL and it is not close. As others have said us UK fans have had a front row seat to the sleaziness that UL has permeated since Pitinos hiring. At least with Duke, I do not disrespect them as I do UL. I do want them both to lose badly always tho. Not sure what I will do when they play this year. Maybe root for the earth to open up and swallow K & Pitino up.
It's like ISIS vs Hitler. Hitler was a long time ago so the hatred fades a bit but ul is the scum of the earth with no sense of morality and they aren't even smart enough to know it. But that's just me.
I dislike Duke less, but they are also more of a threat to us than Louisville. When they play in the regular season I'd rather see Louisville lose, but I'd prefer if Duke loses in a Tournament game.
Like someone else above said, I can at least respect Duke. I think a better question would be Louisville or Indiana, as neither are to be respected in my opinion.