ADVERTISEMENT

Transmission fluid: Change or don't change?

Blueathletics

Senior
Dec 21, 2007
4,928
3,506
113
I've heard it both ways so I thought I'd ask the mechanics on the board

42k miles 2010 Fusion if that helps...
 
I would follow the maintenance schedule in your owner's manual. Those are usually written by the engineers that designed the car. I may do it sooner than recommended if you constantly tow something or use the car as a taxi cab.

Just off the top of my head, 42k seems a bit early.
 
Simple. If the transmission has an external filter, you're OK changing the fluid. If the transmission has an internal filter, leave it alone. It's more trouble than it's worth.
 
Originally posted by argubs2:
There is something about the purple that transmissions crave.
Royal Purple?
3dgrin.r191677.gif
 
Originally posted by GhostVol:
Simple. If the transmission has an external filter, you're OK changing the fluid. If the transmission has an internal filter, leave it alone. It's more trouble than it's worth.
Truth. I did it because I needed to add a cooler for towing. Chrysler auto + internal filter = finished around midnight because I had to have it to get to work the next morning.
 
Depends. If you plan to get rid of the car around 100-130k miles then don't bother. The car should be able to get there without a transmission issue. If you plan to keep the car forever then follow the manufacturer's maintenance plan.
 
Originally posted by BlueRaider22:
If you plan to keep the car forever then follow the manufacturer's maintenance plan.
laugh.r191677.gif
OP's car is Ford Fusion.
 
42000 miles seems a little early, seems like 60-65k is when most manufacturers recommend. It's not that bad of a job, just a little messy, as most transmissions don't have a drain plug. Have to crack the seal on the pan and let it drain.
 
alot of different opinions on it.


the 2002 thru 200? Ford Explorer didn't even have a dipstick or a drain plug. It was built to never need changing (and of course, they failed at alarming rates)

I would change the fluid regularly and if I towed with the car/truck, I'd change it even more than the manufacturers recommendations - if I had a new/newer car.

while I don't claim to be an expert, I've heard more than one person tell me to never flush (different than change) the transmission fluid on a high mileage car if the fluid hasn't been changed regularly.

If I was worried about transmission failure down the road, I'd also consider an external filter and/or a transmission cooler

Heat kills transmissions

This post was edited on 2/18 7:08 PM by TankedCat
 
Had my Accords changed at 30,000. Thats what Honda recommends for the new CVT transmissions. Cost was 59.99 at Honda dealership.
 
Many mechanics claim that breaking the transmission seal can cause issues. That's why the OP is asking. Two different trains of thought on the issue.
 
Originally posted by GhostVol:
Simple. If the transmission has an external filter, you're OK changing the fluid. If the transmission has an internal filter, leave it alone. It's more trouble than it's worth.
^ This
 
Originally posted by Willy4UK:
Originally posted by BlueRaider22:
If you plan to keep the car forever then follow the manufacturer's maintenance plan.
laugh.r191677.gif
OP's car is Ford Fusion.
Was my Mom's car, who died...So I took it off my dad's hands to help him out during a tough time
 
Originally posted by Chuckinden:
My Mercedes has a sealed transmission that doesn't require fluid changes.
I think you and I have talked about this before but I'd do some research on your model. There's a pretty strong contingent out there that MB has been full of crap on their "sealed for life transmissions" and has zero qualms about folks having to replace failed units for *lots* of money.

I'd check out the MB World forums regarding yours, one of the better car forums I've come across, just food for thought and a very interesting place. I've had two AMG models and had both transmissions serviced at Tafel (something they have no problem doing bc they know their claim is bunk)....full dropping and wiping of the pan, each time the fluid was dirty and metal shavings in the pan. Id look into it, just saying.
 
Originally posted by argubs2:
There is something about the purple that transmissions crave.
Purple has electrolytes and transmissions, like plants, crave electrolytes.
 
Originally posted by Blueathletics:

Originally posted by Willy4UK:
laugh.r191677.gif
OP's car is Ford Fusion.
Was my Mom's car, who died...So I took it off my dad's hands to help him out during a tough time
Dammit Blueathletics, you go bringing up sentimental objects and making me feel guilty.
 
Originally posted by Willy4UK:
Originally posted by Blueathletics:

Originally posted by Willy4UK:
laugh.r191677.gif
OP's car is Ford Fusion.
Was my Mom's car, who died...So I took it off my dad's hands to help him out during a tough time
Dammit Blueathletics, you go bringing up sentimental objects and making me feel guilty.
Just getting you back for us having to endure your snot-shot sig
3dgrin.r191677.gif
 
If your trans isn't giving you any problems, you got lucky, leave it alone. If you do anything at all to it, take it to a Ford dealer. There is a TSB on that car for the transmission.
 
Originally posted by ymmot31:

If your trans isn't giving you any problems, you got lucky, leave it alone. If you do anything at all to it, take it to a Ford dealer. There is a TSB on that car for the transmission.
Looked for that TSB but couldn't find anything on it...Even called Ford and gave them VIN
 
I work at a training school for auto repair.

We have 8, UAW, ASE master mechanics teachers.

I ask this same question about changing the trans fluid in my Honda Accord.
It has 208 thousand miles on it now.

I was told that if you had changed the fluid on schedule for the life of the car, then continue to.

But if you had not DO NOT change it now at 208 thousand.

Without a doubt, changing on schedule will substantially increase the life of your transmission.

This post was edited on 2/19 7:55 PM by BlueTick2
 
Originally posted by Blueathletics:

Originally posted by ymmot31:

If your trans isn't giving you any problems, you got lucky, leave it alone. If you do anything at all to it, take it to a Ford dealer. There is a TSB on that car for the transmission.
Looked for that TSB but couldn't find anything on it...Even called Ford and gave them VIN
It took me less than one minute to find this after I saw your post:

Ford 2010 Fusion I4
TSB 09-18-3

* 6F35 - HARSH 3-1 OR 2-1 ROLLING STOP DOWNSHIFT - HESITATION DURING LOW SPEED MANEUVERS - 2-3 OR 3-4 UPSHIFT FLARE COLD STARTS - NO DTCS


Learn research.

Again OP, if your transmission isn't giving you any problems, leave it alone.
 
Reminds me... One of my most favorite bosses of my life... WWII USMC guy, Pacific Theater....
When involved in a discussion similar to this one, concerning crankcase oil changes... Said.
"It says ADD!!! Not _ _ _ _ ing change!!!"
No one argued with Tall Man..........
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT