ADVERTISEMENT

NY Times: Dean Smith’s Shadow Looms Over U.N.C. as It Struggles With a Scandal’s Fallout

mktmaker

Junior
Jun 5, 2001
3,898
2,327
113
Atlanta
Sports Business
By JOE NOCERA FEB. 12, 2016
NY Times
2-13-2016


(remainder at link)


CHAPEL HILL, N.C. — I hadn’t realized when I came here this week that Sunday marked the first anniversary of Dean Smith’s death. But I was quickly reminded; the front page of the University of North Carolinastudent newspaper, The Daily Tar Heel, featured a photograph of Smith, the legendary former U.N.C. men’s basketball coach, along with an articlethat was less about his 879 wins and two national championships than about “the lives he touched and the impact he left.”

I had come to Chapel Hill because I wanted to understand the effect of the terrible “paper class” scandal on the larger university community: the faculty, the alumni, the administration and others who care about what is undoubtedly one of the finest public universities in the country. What I wound up discovering is that there are two shadows hanging over U.N.C. One is the long shadow of the scandal. The other is the even longer shadow of Dean Smith.

If you follow college sports, you probably know about the paper-class scandal, but, just in case, here’s a recap: In 2011, an academic counselor named Mary Willingham began telling Dan Kane, an investigative reporter with The News & Observer in Raleigh, that North Carolina athletes were being steered to sham independent studies classes that never met. Students were required only to turn in a paper that did not even have to be literate. The paper classes went back as far as the 1990s. The grades the athletes were given were always high enough to ensure they were eligible to play.

Incredibly, given that most of these athletes were black, the fraud was being run out of what is now called the Department of African, African-American and Diaspora Studies. The two people orchestrating the fake classes were Julius Nyang’oro, the department head, and Deborah Crowder, the longtime department administrator.

Although the university initially claimed that the scandal had nothing to do with athletics, that was untrue. Kenneth L. Wainstein, a prominent lawyer, issued an authoritative report in October 2014 that noted that nearly half the students in the paper classes were athletes, “even though student-athletes make up just over 4 percent” of the student body. When they were interviewed by Wainstein’s investigators, Nyang’oro and Crowder said that their motivation was to help struggling students, especially “that subset of student-athletes who came to campus without adequate academic preparation.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/13/s...-as-it-struggles-with-a-scandals-fallout.html
 
Tarhole Saint has a nose proportionate to his status as a cheater.

big_nosed_cheater_zpsje3kur8e.jpg
 
That school is petrified that an in-depth investigation will uncover long-time shenanigans and shatter St. Dean's reputation. The guy basically integrated the ACC athletically, how he(and the school) went about doing it and how long it lasted, how deep it went is now in question. IMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatPhight
The ADHD and LD stuff is tragic. If UNC was having Adderall prescribed to its players and they were not having issues that is very sad. If they were over prescribing that is just crazy.
 
I have always said Smith had done less with more talent than any coach ever, loaded rosters year after year, he should have had 10 titles at least and only had two. I remember when they had Worthy, Perkins and Jordan on the same team and lost in the tournament to an Indiana team they should have beaten. If Joe Hall had had those three and lost, Lord knows what would have happened.The man was a very good coach, but now knowing things and seeing as to how things were being run, it's has tarnished his record some.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bigbluelou
The thing about UNC is that for so long they took such pride in claiming to be something that they were not when in truth they were so far from being what they claimed that there are no words to describe the sham they really are.

In today's world it is such sport and so easy to dig up dirt and sling mud on everything and everybody I don't understand why those that are so adept at doing it aren't raining down a landslide of dirt and mud on UNC and the NCAA.
 
Sports Business
By JOE NOCERA FEB. 12, 2016
NY Times
2-13-2016


(remainder at link)


CHAPEL HILL, N.C. — I hadn’t realized when I came here this week that Sunday marked the first anniversary of Dean Smith’s death. But I was quickly reminded; the front page of the University of North Carolinastudent newspaper, The Daily Tar Heel, featured a photograph of Smith, the legendary former U.N.C. men’s basketball coach, along with an articlethat was less about his 879 wins and two national championships than about “the lives he touched and the impact he left.”

I had come to Chapel Hill because I wanted to understand the effect of the terrible “paper class” scandal on the larger university community: the faculty, the alumni, the administration and others who care about what is undoubtedly one of the finest public universities in the country. What I wound up discovering is that there are two shadows hanging over U.N.C. One is the long shadow of the scandal. The other is the even longer shadow of Dean Smith.

If you follow college sports, you probably know about the paper-class scandal, but, just in case, here’s a recap: In 2011, an academic counselor named Mary Willingham began telling Dan Kane, an investigative reporter with The News & Observer in Raleigh, that North Carolina athletes were being steered to sham independent studies classes that never met. Students were required only to turn in a paper that did not even have to be literate. The paper classes went back as far as the 1990s. The grades the athletes were given were always high enough to ensure they were eligible to play.

Incredibly, given that most of these athletes were black, the fraud was being run out of what is now called the Department of African, African-American and Diaspora Studies. The two people orchestrating the fake classes were Julius Nyang’oro, the department head, and Deborah Crowder, the longtime department administrator.

Although the university initially claimed that the scandal had nothing to do with athletics, that was untrue. Kenneth L. Wainstein, a prominent lawyer, issued an authoritative report in October 2014 that noted that nearly half the students in the paper classes were athletes, “even though student-athletes make up just over 4 percent” of the student body. When they were interviewed by Wainstein’s investigators, Nyang’oro and Crowder said that their motivation was to help struggling students, especially “that subset of student-athletes who came to campus without adequate academic preparation.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/13/s...-as-it-struggles-with-a-scandals-fallout.html


49de6124-e9fc-449c-8e78-ce046c4aafe4.jpg


This scene culminates with 20 police cars rolling up on Shawshank and Warden Norton putting one right through his own forehead.

While I hope UNC's scandal doesn't end with anyone offing themselves, it would be fitting if the NCAA came tapping on UNC's door the same way the authorities tapped on Norton's, with a legion of reporters and officials laying out the blueprint for a retroactive vacating of hundreds of wins and a few Final Four banners.

"Make this easy on yourself..."
 
  • Like
Reactions: CatPhight
It's honestly embarrassing the NCAA made that convoluted statement as to why they originally couldn't punish them. You know it's BS, I know it's BS, the NCAA knows it's BS, even UNC* knows it's BS.

Simply embarrassing on the NCAAs part
 
  • Like
Reactions: catben and HICATFAN
49de6124-e9fc-449c-8e78-ce046c4aafe4.jpg


This scene culminates with 20 police cars rolling up on Shawshank and Warden Norton putting one right through his own forehead.

While I hope UNC's scandal doesn't end with anyone offing themselves, it would be fitting if the NCAA came tapping on UNC's door the same way the authorities tapped on Norton's, with a legion of reporters and officials laying out the blueprint for a retroactive vacating of hundreds of wins and a few Final Four banners.

"Make this easy on yourself..."


UNC_cheatz_zpskdybabu3.gif
 
People are saying UofL should get the death penalty. I disagree. Should they get their banners removed? Oh yes, but not the death penalty.

UNC*? They deserve the death penalty

Agreed x 1000 .... anything less will only serve to create a stronger, steady breeze onto a smoldering theme which is to replace/disband/disembowel the NCAA with something different...

Go CATS!
 
It's amazing to me to what lengths people want to go in order to try and keep Dean Smith out of this. It is entirely plausible that he had direct involvement in this given the time period it began, the individuals deeply involved, and comments he made after he retired. At the very least, it warrants an in-depth and honest assessment.

Perhaps people simply can't accept or confront the degree to which they base their value judgements on the most superficial of measures. Just because Smith said the right things about academics, doesn't mean he did the right things.
 
49de6124-e9fc-449c-8e78-ce046c4aafe4.jpg


This scene culminates with 20 police cars rolling up on Shawshank and Warden Norton putting one right through his own forehead.

While I hope UNC's scandal doesn't end with anyone offing themselves, it would be fitting if the NCAA came tapping on UNC's door the same way the authorities tapped on Norton's, with a legion of reporters and officials laying out the blueprint for a retroactive vacating of hundreds of wins and a few Final Four banners.

"Make this easy on yourself..."
He shot himself under the chin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Son_Of_Saul
58334115.jpg


^^^
LOL at this guy's use of the "there"/ "their" component. Almost was a great one!
 
Last edited:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT