Why Joey Votto is the most underappreciated great hitter of his era
Votto has been one of baseball's most productive hitters since the mound was lowered in 1969
Anyway, here is the career wRC+ leaderboard since the mound was lowered in 1969. I've set the minimum at 3,000 plate appearances, giving us a sample of 955 batters.
- Barry Bonds --173 wRC+
- Mike Trout -- 167
- Mark McGwire -- 157
- Joey Votto -- 156
- Frank Thomas -- 154
- Albert Pujols -- 153
- Manny Ramirez -- 153
- Miguel Cabrera -- 152
- Willie Stargell -- 152
- Dick Allen -- 150
By this one all-encompassing metric, Votto has been the fourth-best offensive player since the mound was lowered. He's been 57 percent better than the league average hitter during his career. Don't like the gory math involved with wRC+? Fine. Votto is 14th in batting average (.311), second in on-base percentage (.425), and 26th in slugging percentage (.532) among those 955 players.
This is not a player who is having some tremendously productive years at his peak. Votto has been one of the most productive hitters in Reds history -- among players with at least 1,500 plate appearances, he is first in franchise history in OPS (.957) and OPS+ (156), even better than everyone from the Big Red Machine days -- and one of the best hitters in all of baseball over the last half-century.
Votto is in the middle of another dominant second half, the kind of second half only a handful of players in the game can match. He's very much on a Hall of Fame trajectory and has laid down one heck of a foundation. Votto has the rate stats. Now he just needs to pile up some counting stats, and since he's only 33 and is signed through 2023, he has plenty of career remaining.
Despite all the critics who focus on his RBI totals and resent his willingness to take a walk, Votto is one of the most productive players of his generation and one of the best offensive players of our lifetimes. This is a historically great hitter who deserves more attention for putting together a career than has him on the path to becoming one of the best hitters baseball has ever seen.
https://kentucky.forums.rivals.com/threads/joey-votto.199477/