ADVERTISEMENT

Choose a Package Deal for 2018...

Who would you rather have?

  • Immanuel Quickley and Zion Williamson

    Votes: 56 81.2%
  • Darius Garland and Cameron Reddish

    Votes: 13 18.8%

  • Total voters
    69

MWes11

All-SEC
Apr 22, 2012
7,793
9,796
113
Who would you rather have and why? These seem to be the two package deals everyone is talking about. All four players are in the top 10, per 247Sports.
 
Both is a good choice lol. I'm choosing Quickley and Williamson. Quickley is the recruiting piece for the season like Green was and was Cal's first choice at point guard. Reddish is the better prospect, but Williamson is going to be needed for rebounding and authority inside after the assumed mass exodus after this year from big men on our team.
 
xPyScQ8.jpg
 
Zion and Reddish is a toss up in various ways. But Zion leaves the door open for Barrett in 18, so give me him.

Then Quickley is a much better fit beside Quade than Garland. Bigger. More of a combo.

So they're pretty similar in terms of talent. But Zion/Quickley fit better for our needs and what we're looking to do.
 
I want one from each pool. Williamson doesn't need a point guard to set him up for shots. Shooters like Monk and Booker profit from a good penetrator and a kickout. Williamson creates his own with quickness, back downs, post ups and offensive rebounding put backs. Give me Reddish at the two to spot up and drain that look from three point range. Alexander is going to be as good or better pro as Quickley. He will be back with a years experience and a great feel for the point position. Alexander at point (or Green, seeing he will probably be back and start if he does return) Reddish at the two with Beastmode Williamson at the three would give us a great offensive triangle out front.
 
No right answer here: Quickley seems to want to play for UK and an amazing talent doesn't get any better than that

If it keeps Garland/Reddish away from Duke than bring those two on.
 
Williamson is the best player in the class and Quickly is better than Garland so the choice is easy imo.
Zion is the best player in the country, just doesn't have the #1 ranking.... The eye test says it all to me and haven't seen a player that physically gifted since Lebron.
 
Don't think you can clearly say who the better player is between Quickley and Garland.

I don't think any team recruiting either would turn down a LOI from the other if they could take it tomorrow.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT