The OP is not being crazy here. We are all looking at what 96 accomplished both for that season and in future years, and what 15 almost accomplished that season and in future years. Obviously you can't look at what this team will do in future years (at UK or NBA), nor can we confidently predict what they will do this year. I will say the confidence in this group of players is only surpassed (post Mashburn) by the 96, 10, 12 & 15 teams. 12 wasn't deep like the other 3.
All those teams had flaws, even 96, that because of time maybe we've all forgotten the bad. For example, our "clutch 2014-NCAA-T shooter" (Aaron H) made only 31.6% from 3 in 2015. And Lee gave us so little, that with the Platoon ending not long after Poythress injury, he had trouble getting minutes the last 1/3 of the season. As much as I loved Ulis, he wasn't All-American Ulis in 2015, where he doubled his scoring pace (PPM).
96 is first.
But depending on how the big guys this year play, 24 certainly has a chance to be the 2nd best group in terms of performance.